Are the contact listings from different email services or the same?
I'd import everything into one place, preferably my Gmail account, and use its 'Duplicates' feature to initially weed out/sort similar entries, and then just sit down and edit/merge those findings, hopefully ending up with a final,cleaned up, master contacts list. I'd also do this on a PC with a decent sized monitor. If you're working on a pretty large number of contact entries it'll be easier to see what you're comparing on a larger screen and easier to edit text with a keyboard and mouse than a smartphone screen with its touch interface.