How did you import them? If it was via Google contacts syncing then were the others stored as phone-only contacts rather than Google? That would explain it.
If so, a simple solution is to go into the Fanfare's contacts app and "export" them. This will create a .vcf file (vcard, which is the most widespread format for contacts sharing). Copy it to the new phone and "import" into that phone's contacts.
Only problem is that if you can't export just the ones that weren't copied you may end up with duplicates that you'll need to tidy up. But if the problem is different types of contact you may be able to just export the one type, which would avoid that.