• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Help Static sound when recording video.

Codec

Codec

Android Enthusiast
When I record a video there is an annoying static sound when I play the video back, does anyone else have this issue?
 
Very well documented all over the internet and here on the Forums...No real hard evidence yet whether its hardware or software related.

I say hardware though....
 
Codec said:
I hope it's not hardware.
Click to expand...

email google support about it and see what they say. they will most likely replace it.

mine does that as well but also every mic whole is blocked with glue, Google is sending me a new phone (it actually was delivered today, but wont see it till I get home)
 
Just tries recording a video right after I seen this post. Does it here too. I recorded indoor. I wonder if outdoor is the same?
 
My new one has no hissing...

Just the usual white noise like my
iPhone 5s...So I'd say pretty safe to say its a hardware issue.

Just a follow up...
This is in fact my 3rd nexus from Google.

First one: white 32GB, terrible hissing when recording audio even on 4.4.2

Second: white 32GB, same hissing even on 4.4.2 and a defective vibrate motor.

Third: black 32GB, decided to just return both white versions and go with the Black version. No hissing during audio, and no issues with the vibrate. Prompt for 4.4.2 came down while downloading all my apps, seems fine so far.
 
Just got my replacement, no glue but the static and hissing is just as bad when i record a video, but is fine when placing calls both normal and speaker phone.

This makes me think its a software issue... Other wise phone calls would sound just as bad wouldn't they??

Thought video/ snapchat/ instagram all record with that loud static
 
krs128 said:
Just got my replacement, no glue but the static and hissing is just as bad when i record a video, but is fine when placing calls both normal and speaker phone.

This makes me think its a software issue... Other wise phone calls would sound just as bad wouldn't they??

Thought video/ snapchat/ instagram all record with that loud static
Click to expand...

No, I think it may be a hardware issue. On my previous device, an HTC One X, I had issues with the mic. During calls, the only way I could get people to hear me during calls was to put it on speakerphone. The mic did NOT work in Instagram, Snapchat, Vine, etc. It would record but there was no sound. But, it DID in fact work when recording regular videos using the native camera app. I thought this was odd and did some research. Turns out the noise cancellation mic only comes on during speakerphone & recording videos (apparently only with HTC's camera) and that is what was recording the audio during calls. The main mic was indeed broken and did not work. So only apps that used the second noise cancellation mic would record sound.

My guess is the Nexus 5 is having issues with it's two mics simultaneously recording, or maybe even just one is defective. That would definitely cause issues with static in recordings. It would also explain why some apps may have loads of static but others are crystal clear, because they use different mics.
 
Lona808 said:
No, I think it may be a hardware issue. On my previous device, an HTC One X, I had issues with the mic. During calls, the only way I could get people to hear me during calls was to put it on speakerphone. The mic did NOT work in Instagram, Snapchat, Vine, etc. It would record but there was no sound. But, it DID in fact work when recording regular videos using the native camera app. I thought this was odd and did some research. Turns out the noise cancellation mic only comes on during speakerphone & recording videos (apparently only with HTC's camera) and that is what was recording the audio during calls. The main mic was indeed broken and did not work. So only apps that used the second noise cancellation mic would record sound.

My guess is the Nexus 5 is having issues with it's two mics simultaneously recording, or maybe even just one is defective. That would definitely cause issues with static in recordings. It would also explain why some apps may have loads of static but others are crystal clear, because they use different mics.
Click to expand...

my calls are crystal clear though, speaker phone and normal calls.

video recording/instagram/snap chat all sound identical with the static.

oh well if it is a hardware issue, once google identifies it and corrects the issue, they will have a lot of returns/replacements to send out.

EDIT: there is only static when it is in a quiet environment. I just did a video recording with music playing from my Nexus 7 and it came through crystal clear as if I was playing the song on my nexus 5.
 
krs128 said:
my calls are crystal clear though, speaker phone and normal calls.

video recording/instagram/snap chat all sound identical with the static.

oh well if it is a hardware issue, once google identifies it and corrects the issue, they will have a lot of returns/replacements to send out.

EDIT: there is only static when it is in a quiet environment. I just did a video recording with music playing from my Nexus 7 and it came through crystal clear as if I was playing the song on my nexus 5.
Click to expand...

The Nexus 5 may handle the mics differently from the one x and use only one mic for calls and speaker. Its only a theory. But you're completely right about the replacements. And just as much as Google doesn't want to replace thousands of devices for free, I don't want to have to send mine in an be phone less for weeks.

SMH Google. Just when we thought you got everything right this time.
 
Lona808 said:
The Nexus 5 may handle the mics differently from the one x and use only one mic for calls and speaker. Its only a theory. But you're completely right about the replacements. And just as much as Google doesn't want to replace thousands of devices for free, I don't want to have to send mine in an be phone less for weeks.

SMH Google. Just when we thought you got everything right this time.
Click to expand...


you wouldn't have to be phoneless, they send you a replacement and then you send your phone back in the same shipping box, they cover all costs of shipping also.
 
krs128 said:
you wouldn't have to be phoneless, they send you a replacement and then you send your phone back in the same shipping box, they cover all costs of shipping also.
Click to expand...


However they do put a hold on the Funds with you CC until they receive the original one back though...I just did it and ended up sending both defective ones back and ended up placing a whole new order for s black one....which is Good so far
 
Well just got my replacement and still has static sound when playing back a video, sigh, I wonder if this can be fixed with an update?
 
I don't know how you can possibly think this is a hardware issue. Take the same video with your default camera app and listen to the sound quality. It's probably crystal clear. It is for me at least. But whenever I record something on Snapchat in a loud atmosphere, especially with loud lower frequencies, the quality is awful. It's most definitely a software issue. Idk what Snapchats problem with Android is but they really should fix it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom