I think there's a reviewer's rule that S/AMOLED/+ _must_ always win over LCD of any type - unless it's an iPhone. Note those same reviewers that always choose OLED types tend to always highly rate the iP4 - the other criticism of LCDs fall away in praise of the magically retinal Apple display.
Predicted first real hands-on review of the Evo 3D:
While the screen was bold, crisp and clear, with excellent colors we can't help but wonder how much better it would be if they'd left off the 3D gimmick. And it's no good in sunlight or at producing blacks because it's an LCD.
Predicted review if Apple does 3D:
While it's an LCD, the retinal display with the new 3D feature once again schools everyone with what a display should be. Is there anything the new iPhone can't do?
I crack me up. Srsly tho, those are my predictions.
PS - The Engadget and Slashgear reviews spoke highly of the battery and responsiveness as I recall, fwiw.