Yeah, it is more of a guide. You can't tell if your battery is defective just from that first ~10 percent. You need to compare how long it lasts for the full charge. With very high use (watching a couple movies back to back, girlfriend talking your ear off continuously, etc) you should get 4-6 hrs I think. With normal use you shouldn't have a problem lasting all day. If you are hardly using your phone and still have to charge it in the middle of the afternoon, then you might have a bad battery.