In a low voice so only my companions hear me...
"We can split up among the two vessels, or maybe see about towing theirs behind us. If we run into trouble from someone else being able to use the cannons from both ships would be good. Towing them would make it much harder to navigate quickly. "
"We could see about taking them by surprise and capturing them and just taking the ship, I am not super comfortable keeping them around. That ship has lifeboats so we can leave them in one of those and call someone to pick them up. Or drop them off in some neutral territory. "
Looking around...
"What do you guys think? Any other ideas? We could just kill them as well. I am very leery about them for some reason. Things just don't add up, but I am not too keen to just kill them. "