Adding them to the phone or your email account? (Adding them to the email account puts them on Google's cloud and sort of protects against loss of data, even if the phone loses it.)
As to why it's happening, it could be operator error or it could be a defective phone. (Or, and I've seen it happen, you know someone who thinks it's fun to confuse you.)
Create a free account here if you want to continue discussing it, so you can post your replies to this thread and everyone can follow the conversation in one place.