• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Game of Thrones

Anyone thing this season will go beyond book two? I'm just about done reading book two.
 
Ok Liked the way it went carried the plot on without too much preamble or faffing around and introduced the new characters and still left lots of mystery about them. The new locations look excellent! However wasnt too happy with CGI wolf :S
 
Can't wait for Sunday..

game-of-thrones-logo-1.jpg
 
ok liked the way it went carried the plot on without too much preamble or faffing around and introduced the new characters and still left lots of mystery about them. The new locations look excellent! However wasnt too happy with cgi wolf :s

+9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
 
Fantastic show, based on amazing books. Season two is shaping up to be just as well done as season 1.
 
Absolutely love this show. I actually just started watching it a few days ago. They have the whole first season on demand, I watched them all in 3 days. I got caught up tonight with last weeks episode, unfortunately I just finished it, so I couldn't watch tonight's, but I dvr'd it.

I'm into all this kind of stuff. Love reading forgotten realms books, playing the elder scrolls games etc.

Poor Ned Stark.. I was truly angry when they beheaded him..
 
So what do folks think of the Blackwater battle? I thought it was good probably the best episode for this season so far.
 
I love this show and have seen all but the last episode!! I didn't read the entire thread in case there were any spoilers.... I missed last nights show due to our deck being rebuilt. The dish was mounted on one of the railings, so it's not plugged in right now (lucky Supernatural season finale already aired else Id be highly upset lol). Kinda new to the Dish Network, so I haven't even looked to see if we have access to previous episodes.

My fav characters are Tyrion Lannister and Jaqen H'ghar. I think Arya and Jaqen should be married when she gets older... they have good chemistry on screen.
 
I love this show and have seen all but the last episode!! I didn't read the entire thread in case there were any spoilers.... I missed last nights show due to our deck being rebuilt. The dish was mounted on one of the railings, so it's not plugged in right now (lucky Supernatural season finale already aired else Id be highly upset lol). Kinda new to the Dish Network, so I haven't even looked to see if we have access to previous episodes.

My fav characters are Tyrion Lannister and Jaqen H'ghar. I think Arya and Jaqen should be married when she gets older... they have good chemistry on screen.

Yeah, Tyrion and Arya are my favorites. Well you know HBO replay their shows and the finale is Sunday. I'm disappointed with only ten shows for the season.
 
I enjoyed it, but there were a few key scenes from the book that I wish were included.

I know we can't have it all, but I think they did a better job keeping to the story in season 1. I keep waiting for some pivotal characters to show up, and am now worried they never will!
 
I enjoyed it, but there were a few key scenes from the book that I wish were included.

I know we can't have it all, but I think they did a better job keeping to the story in season 1. I keep waiting for some pivotal characters to show up, and am now worried they never will!

I heard book 2 was split for two season.
 
Hello all, hope no one minds me joining in. I've read books 1 and 2, and have been more than satisfied for the most part about how the show has adapted them. Keep this in mind, since the rant I'm about to go on might make it seem like I feel otherwise. Dany stamping her feet and swearing violence against people has become quite tiresome, but that's probably a pretty common sentiment, I'd wager.

I have to say that I was actually pretty disappointed with the last episode. I liked the inital wildfire scene; however, let's not forget that in the books that part was much, much more prolonged. The boat exploding only crippled a part of Stannis' fleet, not the entire group. The show completely dismissed the genius tactics of Tyrion making the chain across Blackwater Bay to trap the fleet once they'd moved in, and the catapults throwing more wildfire were nixed as well. This ties into the scene where Mandon Moore attacks Tyrion; in the books, this was in the water, but in the show, they were forced to move it onto land.

Also, I have to say that the fight scenes were really pretty lame. To this point, the show has done an excellent job of making a small number of people SEEM like a very large group of people, through clever use of camera shots, etc.; however, Ep9 totally failed to live up to that. It was very patently obvious during many points throughout the episode that they were working with a pretty small number of people. The walls also seemed very... short. Did anyone else notice that? The whole set just looked very amateur, the ladders, the walls, etc.

I really enjoy Arya's storyline. Though she also has a little bit of spoiled brat to her, it's being quickly culled out by her harsh life experiences. I liked the portrayal of Jaqen, though IIRC he almost never used personal pronouns like "I" or "you" in the books, where he seems to do it pretty often in the books. However, I think my favorite part is the interplay between Arya and Gendry - I could see them ending up together. (To those who've read the later books, don't spoil it! :p )

I continue to hold faith in GRRM and the HBO writers, as for the most part they've done a fantastic job, and I fully expect the finale this weekend to be fantastic.
 
I understand what you are saying Razor, but I don't expect them to get every detail of the book when transferring it film. The thing with reading is we as the reader have our own vision to the story, when you go see a movie or tv show we are seeing it through someone else vision and it's difficult for them to put everything on the screen. I think they are doing a good job overall even if I know that certain part wasn't in the book.
 
Razor, I added hide tags so that those who haven't seen the episode (like me :p) aren't spoiled. :)
Okay, thanks! Sorry about that. :)
I understand what you are saying Razor, but I don't expect them to get every detail of the book when transferring it film. The thing with reading is we as the reader have our own vision to the story, when you go see a movie or tv show we are seeing it through someone else vision and it's difficult for them to put everything on the screen. I think they are doing a good job overall even if I know that certain part wasn't in the book.
Yeah, you're right of course. My critique about the fight scene was a little more technical; as I mentioned, they'd previously done a great job of that (ie. Season 1), and I am very much pleased with the show overall.
 
Hello all, hope no one minds me joining in. I've read books 1 and 2, and have been more than satisfied for the most part about how the show has adapted them. Keep this in mind, since the rant I'm about to go on might make it seem like I feel otherwise. Dany stamping her feet and swearing violence against people has become quite tiresome, but that's probably a pretty common sentiment, I'd wager.

I have to say that I was actually pretty disappointed with the last episode. I liked the inital wildfire scene; however, let's not forget that in the books that part was much, much more prolonged. The boat exploding only crippled a part of Stannis' fleet, not the entire group. The show completely dismissed the genius tactics of Tyrion making the chain across Blackwater Bay to trap the fleet once they'd moved in, and the catapults throwing more wildfire were nixed as well. This ties into the scene where Mandon Moore attacks Tyrion; in the books, this was in the water, but in the show, they were forced to move it onto land.

Also, I have to say that the fight scenes were really pretty lame. To this point, the show has done an excellent job of making a small number of people SEEM like a very large group of people, through clever use of camera shots, etc.; however, Ep9 totally failed to live up to that. It was very patently obvious during many points throughout the episode that they were working with a pretty small number of people. The walls also seemed very... short. Did anyone else notice that? The whole set just looked very amateur, the ladders, the walls, etc.

I really enjoy Arya's storyline. Though she also has a little bit of spoiled brat to her, it's being quickly culled out by her harsh life experiences. I liked the portrayal of Jaqen, though IIRC he almost never used personal pronouns like "I" or "you" in the books, where he seems to do it pretty often in the books. However, I think my favorite part is the interplay between Arya and Gendry - I could see them ending up together. (To those who've read the later books, don't spoil it! :p )

I continue to hold faith in GRRM and the HBO writers, as for the most part they've done a fantastic job, and I fully expect the finale this weekend to be fantastic.

My thoughts exactly. The show, while great, doesn't adequately showcase Tyrion's genius.

It's been a while since I read the books, so I think it's time to pull them out again.
 
Back
Top Bottom