Gmail notifications not notifying?

[OstrichSaK]

I get hundreds of emails every day and I currently get a notification but no audio tone or vibrate as it would be going crazy. This is how I want my general email notifications set up. So that part is fine.

What I do want however is for starred messages to play a tone/vibrate similar to my text messages. I went into Gmail and then Manage Labels within the menu and I confirmed that 'Starred' is set to sync all and ring, vibrate, notify once. This to me seems like it should be notifying the way I just described that I'm looking for but there is no different notification for starred messages the way I had hoped.

What am I doing wrong here?

 

[OstrichSaK]

Anyone have any thoughts on this?

 

[!on]

Should work if you are given the option for each ?

I would clear data in manage settings, then set each one up again. Not ideal, but process of elimination, etc...

 

[OstrichSaK]

Should work if you are given the option for each ?

I would clear data in manage settings, then set each one up again. Not ideal, but process of elimination, etc...

Surely there has to be a simple setting I'm missing or something. I don't really feel like clearing everything out only to set everything up again because I feel like I'll be at the same place I was before.