I would contact Rearth. They have a 30 day satisfaction guarantee policy. If you don't like the product they will give you a full refund.
I just realized that I bought the Clear plus on Amazon. I didn't know it was the same one that came bundled with the case. I really like it. It's a great screen protector. I haven't had any issues with it. It has extremely solid reviews on Amazon. Its almost a perfect rating with over a 100 reviews. Someone must have been defective or wrong with the install.
The positive reviews were the reason I went with the bundle kit than simply the case by itself. Saved a few bucks and got free shipping. Would have had to pay for shipping on amazon since I don't have a prime account. The bundle only comes with one screen protector though, so it probably evens out. Glad you like it. I'm impressed as well. Hopefully, I still will be in a few days.

Too bad they don't make the same thing that covers all four edges of the phone. I don't drop my phone very often but it does happen occasionally and I just don't want to risk it. Most of my cases (I have lots!) are made from TPU and they are really easy to slip on and off. Since the one you have is a one piece hard case maybe that's why they don't cover the top and bottom of the phone. Maybe it would be too hard to install/remove without it being a two piece case.
