• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

My OS debate is over, im going Android. Need to decide on phone.

Nick-Bit

Newbie
I just got got done LITERALY spending 3 hours at my local AT&T store (to the shagrin of the people working there im sure since I was kinda pestering them and I think you irritate anyone working off comition when you just browse for 3 hours) and after testing the Iphone 4, Motorola Atrix and the HTC Inspire, I have come to the conclusion that I want to get a Android phone. I like how Android does theyres interfaces and how they lay stuff out more then iOS. I realized that my big hangup with the Android was the game aspect and the app aspect. I was afraid that if I went android, I wouldnt get the apps and games I wanted that Itunes had. Well, after thinking about it some more, I realized that I have really wained from handheld gaming over the years. Sure, ill buy the new DS and PSP when they come out at some point, but really im not that big into it anymore, meaning gaming wasnt really a massive point in deciding between the two. Chances are both are going to have the same fun bite sized game that super popular either simulatneously or at some point down the line, and im sure ANdroid is going to start to get more and more full feature games as time goes by (atleast I hope) However, if it dosent, I dont think itll be that big of a deal to me. I realized that im going to be using this smartphone more for cool apps then games. And speaking of apps, I browsed through the android store to try and find the apps I know I would want day 1 with my smart phone, and they were on both marketplaces or they had a equivalent. Twitter, Facebook, Youtube, pandora, gamefly gamescenter are on both OS's, and those are the ones I know I DEFINETLY want on day one. And honestly, really im going to love the android anyway because its my first smartphone, so people that have had both in the past may think its not as good as iphone, but really ill still be in awe probaly with whatever I get because its exposing me to a whole new world.

So, now comes the time to decide on a Android phone. Like I said, I have AT&T. Wished I had Verizon. Nothing i can do. So now I need to pick the right Android phone. Ive tested out nearly everything on the Atrix and the Inspire, and ive come to these conclusions:

Atrix: I think the screen and speed was better then the Inspire. Web browsing seemed more responsive, particularly on scrolling and pinch zooming. Camera was worse and I thought the UI wasnt as good as the inspire, but UI wasnt unnavigable. I thought the keybord was worse than the Inspire, but I dont know if I can change this. I dont know how the Atrixs 4G speeds are.

Inspire: I thought the UI, Camera and Keyboard were better then the Atrix. battery life is worse then Atrix, which concerns me. Is technicaly weaker then the Atrix with its 1 core Processor which concerns me on how itll perform in the coming years. Reviews say 4G speeds arent great (dont know if that can be fixed with Updates)

Basicaly, if I can have the Atrix's muscle in the Inspire 4G with a better battery life and screen, that would be perfect, but both of these phones have pros and cons that im having trouble deciding on which are more important to me. Basicaly its down to Atrix having more processing power and better screen versus Inspire with the better UI and Camera with better keyboard. And my worrys with the Atrix is the UI and camera and my worrys with the Inspire are the single core processor, battery life and supposed bad 4G speeds. Im not sure if I should be worrying about 4G speeds when deciding since 4G is pretty limited right now.

I did notice that the Inspire seemed plenty fast, however Atrix was faster.

I should note I have no interest what so ever in that asanine laptop dock for the Atrix.

So, what do you guys think is the better phone for me? The Atrix or the Inspire. Should I be worrying about the Inspire single core CPU? I would like to have some future proofing, however i dont know if I want to sacrafice UI and Camera for it.
 
If I were you, id get the inspire.

Would you rather have a 400 horsepower chevy or a 300 hosepower bmw?

(htc=bmw. moto=chevy.)
 
It depends on whether you want to install custom roms. Motorola is infamous for encrypting their bootloaders, and pretty much all the developers have given up on trying to crack it.

HTC on the hand has the highest number of developer support. Both of the most popular custom roms out there, CyanogenMod and MIUI are based on HTC phones.
 
It depends on whether you want to install custom roms. Motorola is infamous for encrypting their bootloaders, and pretty much all the developers have given up on trying to crack it.

HTC on the hand has the highest number of developer support. Both of the most popular custom roms out there, CyanogenMod and MIUI are based on HTC phones.

I dont care about installing custom ROMs. Honestly, I think im going with the Inspire. First of all, I dont think many things are going to need a dual core processor for a while, and by that point ill be eligable for another upgrade. Also, I really like the HTC interface. If im stuck with a phone for 2 years, I might as well like how the interface works. And honestly, the phone seems plenty fast to me.
 
Good on you for spending time with several devices in the store; I do the same thing before a purchase. Then I'll leave and let things settle a bit to see which one I "miss," so to speak.

I agree with those here who are recommending the HTC Inspire, for many reasons already pointed out. Verizon does not have it, otherwise I may well have made that choice myself.
 
Good on you for spending time with several devices in the store; I do the same thing before a purchase. Then I'll leave and let things settle a bit to see which one I "miss," so to speak.

I agree with those here who are recommending the HTC Inspire, for many reasons already pointed out. Verizon does not have it, otherwise I may well have made that choice myself.

Dont you guys have that Thunderbolt phone? Isnt that basicaly same thing but more expensive?
 
One point on battery life. I've got a Desire, and it is my first smartphone. The battery life was a shock. I get about a day if I'm careful, though I do top it up on the usb at work so I don't have to worry about it. I hate having to think and worry about the battery though, and switching off all the cool features to save battery. I got caught out the other week at an airport when my flight was delayed and I ran out of charge and couldn't phone home. Just ordered an external battery pack off Amazon now which can charge it to full twice from flat (according to the reviews!) This should hopefully make battery life irrelevant - especially as it gets older. Battery life does vary between handsets, but how you use it will also affect it. Depending on how important this is to you - you may want to give some thought to this.
 
One point on battery life. I've got a Desire, and it is my first smartphone. The battery life was a shock. I get about a day if I'm careful, though I do top it up on the usb at work so I don't have to worry about it. I hate having to think and worry about the battery though, and switching off all the cool features to save battery. I got caught out the other week at an airport when my flight was delayed and I ran out of charge and couldn't phone home. Just ordered an external battery pack off Amazon now which can charge it to full twice from flat (according to the reviews!) This should hopefully make battery life irrelevant - especially as it gets older. Battery life does vary between handsets, but how you use it will also affect it. Depending on how important this is to you - you may want to give some thought to this.

Well, I dont know how the Inspire compares to most smart phones as far as battery goes. Or wether or not the battery life of about 6 hours is that big of a deal.
 
I'd say Atrix, dual cores are becoming the new thing so might as well get the latest since more apps will probably be taking advantage of them
 
I was going through the same phase. I had the atrix for three weeks. Then went with the inspire. I think the inspire was a better choice. Atrix looks good specs wise but really I couldnt tell most of the time.

I wanted lte so moved on to verizon and got the thunderbolt which feels almost the same as the inspire but has many extra details I like but thats irrelevant.

All in all though to be honest these are all great phones. If they weren't we wouldn't be talking about it and own same phone.

I really think youd be happier with the inspire.

Goodluck
 
SE Xperia X10 Mini. But it is compact Handset. 2.6"' or 2.8'' touch screen only but offering 5MP and other all features a high end mobile can offer.
Another is LG Optimus but offering Android 1.6 V.

Videocon mobile just launched Android 2.1 device called Zeus. It is high end device but may cost you more than 15K.
Motorola Backflip is also a good Android device but available around 17K or more in market.
 
SE Xperia X10 Mini. But it is compact Handset. 2.6"' or 2.8'' touch screen only but offering 5MP and other all features a high end mobile can offer.
Another is LG Optimus but offering Android 1.6 V.

Videocon mobile just launched Android 2.1 device called Zeus. It is high end device but may cost you more than 15K.
Motorola Backflip is also a good Android device but available around 17K or more in market.
If you are looking at cheap phones:
SE X10 Mini is a bad choice - small screen and stuck at old Android v2.1.
LG Optimus One is a better choice.
 
Back
Top Bottom