• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Non-threaded SMS?

Still don't see how it matters. The texts have a timestamp attached to them which tells you when they came in. They are arranged in order, which tells you which ones came in first. The subject matter does not change, so you'd still be able to quick scan a list...they would just be in one list instead of a ton scattered all over the place. In fact, as someone whose career will involve emergency pages, if my employer uses texts, I'd prefer to have threaded ones, because then I can go back and find old ones easily in case I need them.

The issue for me is, they are arranged within 1 item, a "thread", based on "sender". In my case, that sender is a "functional" Id set up on each of several Unix servers to run our app, so each one has a unique email address involving the hostname, and thus would be lumped into separate threads, for example, 4 threads for the Id on each of the 4 servers in a "production" group. I want their messages listed individually by time so I can see what action occurred on which server across the group, and when, just from the messages list.

The subject includes the server, an action, and the TIMESTAMP, so they change all the time (as intended). Thus I can see the startup on server1 failed, or if server2 was shut down unexpectedly, or server3 had an out-of-memory error, etc. I usually delete most such messages after I check them, but not ones I may need to save for "evidence", or just checking out later. Having them lumped together in a thread simply based on where they came from is no help for my purposes, but maybe that would work for you - "YMMV".

Also, I find that I frequently fatfinger several adjacent items in a list on the Android touch screens, so I could lose a message that needs to be saved if it is adjacent to others I do not want inside a thread (another reason I hate capacitive screens and their "twitchiness" vs resistive screens that I can control more precisely with a stylus or fingernail).

Enjoy your threads - they just do not work for me based on 10 years of this kind of work.

UPDATE:
FWIW, I have found that SMS Composer does the job for me.

Also, it occurred to me that it might help to explain my messaging usage pattern in that I have no interest in retaining the computer-generated messages from my work usage more than a few days at most. My personal messages are so few (half dozen a month or so) that threading in that case might be helpful or not, but hardly matters as few as they are - the work usage is what drives my message organizing criteria.
 
GO SMS Pro, open it, you'll see threaded conversations. Swipe from left to right. You will see folders. Pres menu>folder options>enable traditional folders. Then you'd see the inbox, outbox, sent, etc. You can also make your own folders, say "IMPORTANT", "JOKES", whatnot.

If you receive a text that you want to save as a favorite or important, long press on the message in the conversation view, then select save as.

Still havent found a way to make this default, but I dont need it. The developer responds quickly though, so you may send a request to have an option to enable folder view as default.
 
Try Classic SMS View
classicsms1.JPG


Click here for an Android Forums Discussion of Classic SMS
 
For me the most annoying thing threaded SMS's is that, on the main menu, the sms counter reverts to nothing (i.e. it disappears) if you read only one new sms in a particular thread. My wife's eyesight is not that good, and when I send her a couple of SMS's, she only reads the first one and does not know that there are others (unless she reads them all at once) once she returns to the Messages icon. Surely others have come across this infuriating "feature" ? Does anyone know if this particular behaviour would disappear if I installed one of the unthreaded apps mentioned in these postings, because, strictly speaking, it's not actually a threaded / unthreaded issue ?
 
GO SMS Pro, open it, you'll see threaded conversations. Swipe from left to right. You will see folders. Pres menu>folder options>enable traditional folders. Then you'd see the inbox, outbox, sent, etc. You can also make your own folders, say "IMPORTANT", "JOKES", whatnot.

If you receive a text that you want to save as a favorite or important, long press on the message in the conversation view, then select save as.

Still havent found a way to make this default, but I dont need it. The developer responds quickly though, so you may send a request to have an option to enable folder view as default.


+1. You can set it to spin from one to the other as if the options are on the sides of a cube. I too like the "traditional" way of looking at texts. For those that can't understand why anyone would want to view texts this way rather than "threaded" then they have their answer with that statement ..... :confused:

Dave
 
Even dumb phones these days are offering threaded sms. I personally can't imagine not having it anymore. I would rather see everything I've said to or received from my girlfriend together than have random texts from my buddy Gary and my dad lumped in the middle of an inbox only folder. Just my (and many others preference).

I think that's the point though - there are just as many people who would disagree with you as there are who would agree. We're all different :D. I personally think it's ludicrous to have threaded messages grouped according to person - I often get messages from unknown senders (business) or organisations whose name I can't always recall. What do I do then? Scroll through 200 SMS messages to find the right one? So why not provide people with both options and let them decide what's best for them? :confused:
 
If you prefer inbox,sent,draft menu style sms, use Pansi sms. Swipe and you can see the sms in threaded style. Can also create custom folders.
I like this app, but this sms app lacks two important features, blacklist sms and Private sms box.
I have requested the developer for the feature. Hope you do the same.
 
Back
Top Bottom