I'm not too familiar with the CLIQ, but personally I suggest LauncherPro. It is, by far, the best launcher I have ever used.
It has the 3D app drawer, customizable dock, scrolling dock, super smooth and fast, etc.
As far as the two you are looking at, I think either one would be ok. Again, I have only used them on my Droid and can't speak for how they would run on the CLIQ. Both have themes that can be applied and both have their perks.