• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Real Cell Phone Boosters?

JAJameson2010

Android Enthusiast
100% not sure where to post this... I just spent 10 mins trying to decide and am still clueless!

We weekend at a camping trailer in a pretty remote area. Sprint cell phone service is a bit spotty out there. We have no internet, etc. It was recommended that I try this

Amazon.com: Wilson Electronics SOHO Cell Phone Signal Booster Kit for Small Office and Home Office with Omni-Directional and Panel Antennas: Cell Phones & Accessories

But it's a pretty large price tag! Is there anything comparable for a little less? We have an airrave thing at home that works perfectly but we don't have internet at the trailer.

Anyone have any brilliant ideas? :)
 
who's your cell provider? See if they'll provide one.

I've heard from some people that Verizon wireless will actually provide one for customers who complain about not getting coverage and wanting to cancel.
 
Sprint has provided me with a little mini tower for my home, but it requires internet connection. They don't offer anything that works without it.
 
It operates on the right MHz. But I would still be skeptical. I would enjoy your weekend without a cell phone or stop spending the weekend in the middle of nowhere.
 
I just called Sprint and asked if they had a solution and they have nothing that can operate without an internet connection. I was hoping they would have a magical answer for me! But the guy on the phone seemed more clueless than I was! LOL

I could easily survive without the phone if it wasn't every weekend from April/Oct. ;) It's relaxing out there but I would love to be able to sort through my email occasionally. The kicker is that Verizon has the best service out there but I will be smartphoneless before I give that company another red cent.
 
In your predicament I would, likely, spend some time evaluating a few of the virtually innumerable "homemade cellphone booster" methods to be found by even a casual Internet search. I would spend considerable time thinking about whether the designs should, logically, work from a "common sense" standpoint and trying to evaluate them based on scientific(physics) principles. I think I would, likely, end up building one of the coffee can type boosters to, at least, see what happens.

http://www.metacafe.com/watch/750707/how_to_make_a_cell_phone_antenna_under_5_minutes/

http://www.wisebread.com/no-signal-5-quick-ways-to-boost-your-cell-phone-reception-updated

http://www.ehow.com/way_5852197_diy-cell-booster.html

http://www.google.com/search?q=do+it+yourself+cellphone+signal+booster

www.google.com/search?q=homemade+cellphone+signal+booster

www.google.com/search?q=diy+cellphone+signal+booster

Boosting cellphone signal has, I would think, got to be one of the very top concerns for a large percentage of cell phone owners; so, I do not think there is any shortage of potentially good, homemade, designs.
 
Wow! I had no idea that I could make these things myself... This could be dangerous! I love arts and crafts projects :P

Thanks so much!!!!!!!!!
 
Since the OP didn't ask for advice on when to use his phone or what he should be doing while camping, that doesn't really need to be addressed. There is no need to comment or post your opinion on how and when someone uses their smartphone. It is their's to use as they see fit.

This reminds me of something my mother used to tell me, "If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all.";)
 
You can also try this, most of the public safety departments in my area use this in their vehicles. Much less expensive than your original item and it's the same manufacturer. Amazon.com: Wilson Electronics Sleek Cell Phone Signal Cradle Booster for All Cell Phones with Mini Magnet Mount Antenna - For Single User: Cell Phones & Accessories


Thanks! I'm toying with the idea of just trying this... I think the phone has to be in the cradle for it to work though. Maybe I'll research this more. :D
 
You should obtain an amateur radio license and purchase some mobile ham gear. Forget the cellphone and talk to the world. Enjoy the time away from your cell.
 
We weekend at a camping trailer in a pretty remote area. Sprint cell phone service is a bit spotty out there. We have no internet, etc. It was recommended that I try this

Amazon.com: Wilson Electronics SOHO Cell Phone Signal Booster Kit for Small Office and Home Office with Omni-Directional and Panel Antennas: Cell Phones & Accessories

But it's a pretty large price tag! Is there anything comparable for a little less?
If you're not too far away from the nearest cell tower, you can try using an external directional antenna mounted to a pole (or tree etc.) and point it at the nearest tower. This will give you gain without the expense of the amplifier. Just rotate slowly 360
 
Not sure how far away I am from a cell tower... Guess I could look that up somehow. I'll look at that website and try to unconfuse myself. :) Thanks so much!

Right now I'm swaying towards going with a wilson sleek for a car but getting a separate power cord for a wall outlet instead of a car cig lighter. At this rate it will be a next summer project instead of this one, so I have plenty of time to waffle around and find the best solution.
 
You should obtain an amateur radio license and purchase some mobile ham gear. Forget the cellphone and talk to the world. Enjoy the time away from your cell.

LOL Can I get the truckers to read me my emails? Might give Siri (or whatever it's called) a run for her money... :D
 
Not sure how far away I am from a cell tower... Guess I could look that up somehow. I'll look at that website and try to unconfuse myself.
Call tech support and ask. Many posters here (myself included) have reported getting distance numbers from the tech support operator. In my case the number was precise to the hundredth of a mile, which is ~50 feet. If you ask, they might give you a direction vector as well.


Right now I'm swaying towards going with a wilson sleek for a car but getting a separate power cord for a wall outlet instead of a car cig lighter.
I have several cigar socket to 120VAC plug adapters, from $5 up that I bought at Wal-Mart, Best Buy etc. NewEgg is a good online source.

Since the Wilson relies on a really cheap magnetic rooftop antenna, if you don't get the reception you need, you can replace it with a much better antenna. For on the move driving I chose the superb Laird/Antenex Phantom tri-band. (There are newer models that cover the newer bands, like the TRAB806/17103.) The patented Antenex design beats whip antennas, especially in urban and rural canyons where multipath is a problem, but omnidirectional coverage is needed. I have a directional antenna that was designed to stick onto a glass window, but works OK as-is if I point it carefully. And you can still use one of the directional antennas that I linked to before.

I'm dubious about the connectionless design that doesn't actually plug into the phone, but the theory is sound. Please do report back how you found it to use, if you'll be so kind!


At this rate it will be a next summer project instead of this one, so I have plenty of time to waffle around and find the best solution.
So much for my instant gratification, oh well. Not a bad idea, though.
 
Since the Wilson relies on a really cheap magnetic rooftop antenna, if you don't get the reception you need, you can replace it with a much better antenna. For on the move driving I chose the superb Laird/Antenex Phantom tri-band. (There are newer models that cover the newer bands, like the TRAB806/17103.) The patented Antenex design beats whip antennas, especially in urban and rural canyons where multipath is a problem, but omnidirectional coverage is needed.

I'm dubious about the connectionless design that doesn't actually plug into the phone, but the theory is sound. Please do report back how you found it to use, if you'll be so kind!


So much for my instant gratification, oh well. Not a bad idea, though.

Will definitely report back! Glad to know I can just buy a converter for a few dollars instead of a whole new $15 power cord. :) Every little penny counts.

I'm saving your post so I can know which antennas to buy to swap out. I wonder if I could just buy the parts cheaper separately and easily plug it all together...

Right now we are only going out there for one weekend out of the next 5 weeks due to other vacation and travel plans so it would be silly to spend the money now instead of using it for vacation. Then we get into Septish where we only have 4 more weekends out there... Is it really worth the cost for just 5 more weekends this season... Where exactly did the summer go??

I need to get this thing as a Xmas gift so I don't feel frivolousness buying it! :rolleyes:
 
Will definitely report back! Glad to know I can just buy a converter for a few dollars instead of a whole new $15 power cord. :) Every little penny counts.
Before you buy, look for 12V current ratings. The cheap ones can't power much. OTOH it's unlikely that your power booster (which is limited to 2W@800MHz / 3W@1900MHz by law) will consume more than 500mA, which is nothing in 12V land.


I'm saving your post so I can know which antennas to buy to swap out. I wonder if I could just buy the parts cheaper separately and easily plug it all together...
Feel free to PM me if you like. Might even want to get my e-mail so after I'm banned for speaking my mind in the political section... ;)

I assembled mine out of separate parts, which is why I have so many spare parts that I may never use again. I have a Digital Antenna Digital PowerMax DA4000 linear, which was top of the line when I bought it, and still in production at half the price I paid for mine. Still, that's close to $200 for the amp alone. To make a long story short, buying components is nice for serious users and permanent installations, but will cost more.

I called an engineer at WPSantennas.com and was advised that I could get a $16.95 adapter for my Sprint SII and keep on using my existing hardware, but I have to say that I prefer the sheer simplicity of the Wilson Electronics Sleek Cell Phone Signal Cradle Booster that OverByter recommended. (It's 2W max on both bands, which is an insignificant difference.) WPS has it on sale right now for $89.95, which is $5 more than Amazon.com, money well spent if you need tech support or other help. For example you'll want to throw out the useless stubby antenna that comes with the thing and get a proper dual band antenna like the Wilson Cellular Dual-Band Magnetic Mount Cell Phone Antenna (P/N 301103) at $39.95. WPS will make sure that you get any necessary adapters (for free) if you order from them. IJS from a happy customer.

Since you're concerned about the price of 12V adapters, I'll assume that you'll probably not get the Antenex Phantom (costs ~$100 w/ the required mag mount and plug installed) no matter how much I gush about it, but FYI to any lurkers who have the cash and want a truly exceptional antenna design (all the cops are using these with good reason), this is the one to get.

This is probably a good place to say that you should put the external antenna squarely in the middle of your roof for best reception. If you have a sunroof, move it to the middle of the metal part. You need the metal part as a ground plane, and the better you do to make a good ground plane, the better the reception will be. You can use the trunk, and even the rear package shelf (if it's metal), but it's not advisable with passive adapters, and a definite no-no with wireless multi-phone products.


Right now we are only going out there for one weekend out of the next 5 weeks due to other vacation and travel plans so it would be silly to spend the money now instead of using it for vacation. Then we get into Septish where we only have 4 more weekends out there... Is it really worth the cost for just 5 more weekends this season... Where exactly did the summer go??

I need to get this thing as a Xmas gift so I don't feel frivolousness buying it! :rolleyes:
Think of it this way: it could save your family's lives in an emergency. That's never frivolous!

If you're going to unfamiliar places, you actually might want this thing now to use if service gets spotty. I have to make frequent 140 mile trips alone, and sometimes drive cross-country, often away from the major interstates and their consistent cell service. You won't know until you're there, of course.
 
Since the OP didn't ask for advice on when to use his phone or what he should be doing while camping, that doesn't really need to be addressed. There is no need to comment or post your opinion on how and when someone uses their smartphone. It is their's to use as they see fit.

This reminds me of something my mother used to tell me, "If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all.";)

And the person that made that comment would be the first to say "why didn't you have your cell phone with you" if the person were injured out there too.
 
In your predicament I would, likely, spend some time evaluating a few of the virtually innumerable "homemade cellphone booster" methods to be found by even a casual Internet search. I would spend considerable time thinking about whether the designs should, logically, work from a "common sense" standpoint and trying to evaluate them based on scientific(physics) principles. I think I would, likely, end up building one of the coffee can type boosters to, at least, see what happens.

http://www.metacafe.com/watch/750707/how_to_make_a_cell_phone_antenna_under_5_minutes/

http://www.wisebread.com/no-signal-5-quick-ways-to-boost-your-cell-phone-reception-updated

http://www.ehow.com/way_5852197_diy-cell-booster.html

http://www.google.com/search?q=do+it+yourself+cellphone+signal+booster

www.google.com/search?q=homemade+cellphone+signal+booster

www.google.com/search?q=diy+cellphone+signal+booster

Boosting cellphone signal has, I would think, got to be one of the very top concerns for a large percentage of cell phone owners; so, I do not think there is any shortage of potentially good, homemade, designs.

What about smart phones that don't have an antenna connection?
 
What about smart phones that don't have an antenna connection?
Take it from an actual electrical engineer with antenna design experience. DON'T DO ANY OF THOSE THINGS!!! I read the advice and it's all terrible.

There are things called passive radiators that can extend a RF signal. But the ones that actually work were built to exact dimensions for a particular purpose. Anything else...no.

If you want to extend your reception, try to keep metal stuff (and even your hands) away from the phone unless it's a device made specifically for your phone.

There are products like the ones I mentioned below that work with phones with no antenna jacks. Try using one of these, and don't shove any paperclips into holes period.
 
If you're going to unfamiliar places, you actually might want this thing now to use if service gets spotty. I have to make frequent 140 mile trips alone, and sometimes drive cross-country, often away from the major interstates and their consistent cell service. You won't know until you're there, of course.

Your making my head spin with the info! LOL I just sent an email off to WPS Antennas to see if they can help be piece something together that will work.

Will this help my data signal? Or just my phone call signal? Now I'm leaning towards getting this now... LOL
 
Your making my head spin with the info!
Sorry 'bout that. As you can see, I learned a lot from the product development that I was involved with.

Will this help my data signal? Or just my phone call signal? Now I'm leaning towards getting this now... LOL
It will help your 3G (EVDO, EDGE...) data that's in the same band as the voice calls. It can't help the new out-of-band services like WiMAX and LTE, though. (I'm not sure about UMTS.) You should make sure that if you have a "4G" phone, that you turn off the "4G" part. To be safe, turn off all other 2-way radios (Bluetooth, Wi-Fi) while using the booster, unless the instructions say it's OK.

I know this will make your head spin more, but the first generations of cellphone data was done by using variations of the existing major PCS radio specs (CDMA & TDMA) to carry data and voice on the same channels. As data started using up more channels than the systems could support, new standards emerged that separated the data, and put them in different frequency bands.

As of today, all signal boosters that I know of, from the ones you're looking at, to the femtocell devices that use wired Internet to make tiny private cell sites (which is why they're all "3G", BTW) are working within the basic two PCS bands of 800MHz and 1900MHz.

Had enough yet? ;)
 
Hey I actually understood that! (except the part about bluetooth and wifi being a two way radio, but I can follow directions and keep those turned off) That's interesting about why they started coming out with the other signals because of the increased data use. I think I'm starting to piece these things together in my head, so I'm less confused about the freq bands.

But wait... Your telling me my fancy smanchy 4G cell phone is supposed to get 4G signal??? Surely you jest! I'm pretty much rely on 3G and Wifi in daily life.

They haven't emailed me back yet. Probably my email befuddled them all and they have printed it out and are passing it around the office laughing. LOL
 
Back
Top Bottom