Accessories Seidio Innocase Rugged or Otterbox Defender?

[Aqua Solace]

Well, they both seem to be the same price and in the same class, but which will perform better? My Droid is naked and I had quite a scare earlier today when I dropped it. Thanks goodness it landed in the grass rather than the concrete a few centimeters away. To avoid a catastrophe, which case should I get to offer the utmost maximum protection?

 

[Aqua Solace]

Anyone?

 

[Aqua Solace]

Moderator edit: Ah heck, I can't even clean up this post....


BUMP for the OP

 

[cmathis]

Here:

Rugged vs. Defender


Those results aren't all for the X, but the cases are all designed the same.

 

[hurld]

I have both and IMHO the Otterbox is a much better case,great protection,covers the screen, and the bottom buttons are covered. The Seidio has the better holster though. Right now I'm rocking the Defender in the Rugged holster and it fits my needs great, I even had a 4ft drop onto concrete without a mark.

 

[Trooper]

I'm torn myself and with Christmas coming, not sure which one to get!

 

[poof101]

I too have both cases....I got the otterbox based on its good history BUT the case sucks. Received the SeidoRugged today, and I already like it alot more. Had the otterbox for a month and tried to like it but its not worth it. Sell you mines for cheap if you want it.