• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

The Nexus 5 a phone for techies? [RANT]

egernant

Well-Known Member
I realize I'm asking the wrong crowd about this - we're all self-admitted tech nerds on this site. That's why you own a Nexus 5 right? You're a savvy consumer that knows his/her shit. But is the Nexus 5 really a techie's device?

Here's the scoop - my sister in law has had a GS3 for a year and a half and has had some problems with it. I'm the family tech support, so I've seen every problem she's had, and my response (at least internally) is always "this wouldn't be an issue if you had a Nexus phone". Phone running slowly due to bloat, bluetooth issue that Samsung would address in the cancelled KitKat update, you get the point and the list goes on.

She is on Sprint and apparently they are on the no-contract bandwagon now, so she was looking at $600+ for a new phone. Perfect chance to sell her on the $400 Nexus 5, which frankly is the only phone out right now that I'd really want to own (no I'm not saying that the M8 or GS5 are bad - just not for me). I told her the benefits, it all went over her head, but she went into Sprint and asked for a Nexus 5. I think the $400 price tag was all I needed to mention. The rep went out of his way to not sell her that phone. He told her no one buys that phone, it's a phone for "techies" only, blah blah blah, get a Samsung or HTC that costs $700 instead, etc.

Luckily she is stubborn as hell and walked out with a new Nexus 5.

Nexus phones are about the only phone line that I will consistently recommend. Are there compromises? Of course. But it's a great way to avoid headaches down the road with software updates.

I just want to understand why this phone is considered a "techie" phone. Google's stock Android interface is simple, intuitive, customizable, and not overwhelming to a new user (from my perspective). It walks you through the basics right from the start. I have no trouble recommending this phone to even the most tech-illiterate person. Am I doing it wrong? Is this really a techie phone? Am I doing these people a disservice? All I see when I look at a Nexus is a simple UI that puts the user first, not a carrier or a manufacturer. Oh, and the $400 price tag doesn't hurt.

Maybe the rep is paid on commission based on phone price. That would make sense. I'm more just trying to understand the stigma of Nexus being "techie". I wish all Android phones utilized the Nexus software. I think it would give people a better impression of what Android really is and would add consistency to the platform. Help me understand what I'm missing here.

/rant
 
It is very likely that the rep is paid on commission - Samsung and HTC will probably pay them a commission to sell their devices. But Google/LG likely will not pay a significant commission for this lower-cost N5 device.

Regarding the experience, for most of us here, we love the stock interface, with the ability to customize the phone as we want. But a LOT of users like the Touchwiz or sense UI because it already has some of the features that they want. I get it - those features can be added back in easily using other apps, you are preaching to the choir. But there are folks who don't want to have to do that.

Whaddya mean I need to download a widget from the play store? I like the "built in" weather/time widget on my HTC phone!
Whaddya mean the phone won't silence the ringer when I flip it over? I have to download something to make that happen?
etc...

(how else is Apple selling so many devices??) :)

Edit: Any reason why you didn't get the phone from Google Play? (instead of paying more at the Sprint store)
 
All good points.

She didn't realize at the time that she could buy it from Google Play. I had told her to look into the phone and she went out and bought it. Figured she'd have called me first, at which point I would have sent her to Google Play. Anyway, this was easier for her and she still thinks she got a great deal. Might bring it up so she can return it if she wants and order through Play...
 
You should also mention to her that she can take a nexus 5 to any other carrier (except verizon :rolleyes:), so she won't have to buy a new phone if they decide to switch carriers.

That could also be why the sprint reps were pushing away from it, but I also think they work commission (can't remember)


--------------------

As far as the question actually posed:

It is still seen as a techie device. Google doesn't advertise it much, and when consumers are being hit by a billion dollar marketing campaign like Samsung its hard to stand out.

Stock android isnt for everyone. Believe it or not there are actually people out there who like touchwiz :p.

Nexus will remain a "techie" phone as long as its a niche device. Nexus is a developer brand at heart.
 
I bought my Mum the Nexus 4 when it came out, her first smart phone, and I have to agree with you, it is very easy for beginners new to smart phones to use. Saying that, I did simplify the phone a bit for her and replace the icons with nice big words lol, but she soon picked up how to attach photos to email etc and now couldn't be without her smart phone.

That's what I like about the nexus line, they can be as simple, or as technical as you'd like (rooting,ROM'ing etc) and they'll still run as smooth as the first day you got it.
 
I think there is a duality. To most of the public, it's seen as a phone for techies. It's running (basically) stock android with none of the "features" that you get with touch wiz or sense.

However, at the same time, it's not. Of the people I know to own one, I am pretty much the only person that really messes around with it. Every one else pretty much just uses it. They bought it because a)I recommended it, and b)it's cheap when you're not i contract or are buying off contract. So it all depends where you're coming from. The fact that you can get it in some carrier stores is certainly helping get it in the hands of the general public.
 
when it comes to phones I'm very UN-techy. No problems figuring out my nexus 5 though. It does have more issues than my Galaxy Nexus did but I'm just living with those.
 
Have had my Galaxy S3 for almost 2 years and have had no problems whatsoever. Personally, I think Nexus phones are boring and the cameras stink on them all. Aside from timely OS updates, these phones are completely overrated imo. But hey, that's the beauty of Android, there's literally a device for everybody. to each their own right?
 
Have had my Galaxy S3 for almost 2 years and have had no problems whatsoever. Personally, I think Nexus phones are boring and the cameras stink on them all. Aside from timely OS updates, these phones are completely overrated imo. But hey, that's the beauty of Android, there's literally a device for everybody. to each their own right?

Indeed, I went from the S3 to the N5 and it's the best thing I ever did, don't like Touchwiz or the fancy Samsung apps (recently rooted the phone and now it's more to my taste on an AOSP rom)

No issues with the camera, I will concede the Galaxy cameras are top notch however.
 
Im certainly not techy and i like a solid feeling phone not like my wifes plastic toy S3.I like my phones how i like my women,NAKED
 
When I first received my SG3, a week later I had it rooted and was running an AOSP Rom cuz I never found myself needing or wanting to use Touchwiz but it was the only phone I had at the time. When I first purchased my N5 I thought I would be down grading but man I was wrong. This phone is so quick and smooth, not to mention all the other perks. I have no desire of owning anything else....I too like my phones NAKED!! :D
 
Back
Top Bottom