Don't use Straight Talk. They don't like people who don't use the latest and greatest. The only way I revived my old phone was with Verizon Prepaid. Straight Talk outright booted it off their service.
With Verizon Prepaid I only pay $35 a month, use whatever the hell I want, and don't need a data plan (privacy). Total Wireless I thought was T-Mobile but maybe our stock hasn't refreshed, since we still got LG Rebel 3's collecting dust over here.
T-Mobile would be an option if you're lucky enough to live where they exist. Owensboro is a dead zone outside the Walmart parking lot so it's a no-go for me. Sad as they still had Edge service and that meant I could still use a neat slider phone (Samsung Galaxy S Relay) in 2023 if I had service here.