• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

What can you do with S3 that you can't with an IPhone

Why can't you do this? It works on my Mac Mini...

Downloaded Android.com

Then plug in the phone..Choose Camera (PTP) from the drop down menu and a finder window pops up with the phone's folders. Drag and drop...

It was working ok until i updated the firmware (through kies, which only runs on my old windoze laptop). Now it doesn't work at all. When i travel i take the MacBook and swap films and music between it and my phone. Or at least, that's what i used to be able to do until last week.
 
Haven't got a car myself, but If I had, I'd probably want to "dock" and would use that as my trigger :p

I now have Tasker (freaking awesome app btw) and I've used a context where it runs my car stuff when it connects to the bluetooth in my car.

I've also put a widget on my home screen that turns bluetooth on and then opens the bluetooth settings, or turns bluetooth off if it's already on. So now I just have to tap the widget then tap my headset name, and boom... It's ready :D
 
Support an open-source platform that doesn't make its sole existence out of suing the crap out of everyone else.
 
As usual some Android users are obsessed with the iPhone as if they have to continually convince themselves and others that they made the right choice. Be happy and secure in what you have. If you just have to complain at least know what you are talking about.
Also I would not think of having an Android device, and I have had many, without jail breaking it. Same with iPhone which gives you many additional capabilities.

Numbers 3,4,6,9, and 10 are wrong.
Number 5 is irrelevant as there are multiple paid and free apps that do this and Apple will have their own maps app in iOS 6.

I am starting this thread to help other iOS defectors. I would like to find out all of the things that an iPhone can't do compared to an android device to help sway iOS to the light.

1. Widgets
2. Live Wallpapers
3. Pure phone customization. ( themes )
4. Emulators to play old video games. ( snes, n64, mame....)
5. Google Maps Navigation.
6. Access to file explorer like in a pc.
7. Share most files with other apps for easy uploading. (In iOS you are restricted to what applications the app is designed to share with )
8. 4g Speeds
9. Better notification system with control over individual notifications.
10. True multi-tasking.

Am I missing anything guys? I wrote this thread also for some of my friends who are considering the switch after seeing the SGS 3.

this thread should be fun, lol

ignore a call and directly respond via a preset or custom text

BUT

8. tethering
you can tether on an iPhone unless you are doing some weird tethering thing that iPhone can't do?

Also wrong. It is more obvious how to do this in iOS 6 but you can do it in 5 as well.

Install apps from outside of Market - from SDCard or even email attachments.

Wrong. Not designed for consumers but developers can do this and it's easy to find out how. Which is why there are a lot of pirated iPhone apps. Also jail broken iPhones can do this.


Heh. Thats just funny. Flash sucks on android and Adobe has given up and discontinued it.

S beam
pattern unlock - which is much more secure then a passcode
watch videos while texting
change the launcher
app drawer.

A couple of those are just pure android, but still not available on i*hones

Your last three are wrong.

Would it be an idea to *star things that can be done on a jail broken iphone, to give a more accurate comparison? So your list is, "this can't be done on iphone, but these ones can if you jail break it"

Encrypt device?
Encrypt Sd?
Bigger/better use of screen real estate?
Ad-hoc wifi?

It should of course include jail broken iPhones since any serious android user root their phone and more.
IOS is encrypted with a randomized file system and application signing with certificates. It is far more secure than Android and has management tools for thousands of devices which is why corporations choose it over android.
Screen real estate is a potential issue for some but the display is so good that many people prefer it to bigger screens especially for text.
Also can do ad hoc wifi.

SD card - expandable memory

switch batteries on your own

more screen real estate

voice commands - for camera, call rejection, call answer

briefing alarms - for scheduled news and weather delivery

browser choices - I think iPhones only allow for stock and now Firefox (sort of)

Android allows you to break free of the iTunes environment

I'm just laughing reading some of these they are so far off.
Batteries really only matter if you are traveling and you can't take them on airplanes. iPhone's have had much better battery life making it less of a necessity. Some Android phones are coming sealed now too.
Wrong about voice commands
There are many browsers for iPhone including chrome and have been for a long time. You can make a browser other than safari the default on a jail broken iPhone but few people see the need to.
iTunes is far preferable to most people than the scope of what android offers but you can sync via wifi and iCloud which provides far more capability and better polish than anything google offers and it's free. I can't remember the lastt time I synced to iTunes.

Use a default browser other than Safari...

You can make any browser default on a jail broken iPhone.

TASKER!

The fact that this open source OS allows consumer access to "ALL" sensors/events/timers/... COMPLETELY sets ANY Android device apart from IOS.

It sometimes takes months of negotiation with Apple to release an app that makes use of certain sensors. Often this is because Apple has their own product in the works that is similar to what is already developed.

There are several third party apps that do the same thing.

Way wrong. I have been jailbreak/rooting iPhones and Android since the beginning of each. It's quite easy to do iOS 5, easier by far than on many current android phones.
Most iOS users don't care about custom Roms because apple doesn't allow carrier bloat ware on their phones and they don't put any there either.
Really? Upgrades? You do know all iPhones get upgrades from Apple? Which is why most iPhones are on the latest version of the os and most android phones aren't. You are too used to the mess that is Android fragmentation which doesn't exist with apple. Most of the features of the upcoming iOS 6 will be on the 3GS a phone released in early 2009.

Ease of Rootability -- Try to jailbreak an iPhone what a mess!

Complete ROM changeout/flash by consumers -- this is not only an easy practice now but in the communities it is fully accepted (minus the vendors saying it will void warranty). This one is very important since if your device is feeling old and tired you can simply Flash a new ROM in that completely or near completely changes the look, feel, and useability of the device. Want the newest OS update but the vendor has not released it yet? For most devices the new OS update is supported in the dev community far earlier than vendor OTA releases.

Ability to Theme (I know already listed but needs expansion) -- You can make your Android look, feel, operate, just like an iPhone. Theme changes imply that you are ONLY changing the look of the device when in fact you are often changing the UI drastically to meet your needs. Look at HUBs UI on YouTube Asus Transformer: Hubs Navigation Tutorial - YouTube. These are stock Tablet devices that are making use of applications/widgers from the market to fully change the UI experience.

You can probably make the UI of an S3 look like an iPhone but no chance of making an iPhone look like an S3 ;)

I don't know why you would want to. Any self respecting S3 owner gets rid of touch wiz. But you can install android on a jail broken iPhone as well as themes and other customizations including launchers.

No you can't. Especially on a jail broken iPhone.

I think of android as an enthusiast OS. You can do a lot more with it. It's not always easy to use and sometimes getting it to work with all of your third party accessories can be difficult, but it is a lot more capable, so the trade off is worth it.

I could list hundreds of things the S3 could do that the iPhone can't, but my advice to anyone who wants to know is to try them both out.

You obviously have no experience with Apple to say that.

Apple is too smart to copy the features of the Galaxy S3, they probably have plans for their next ten iPhones because of the way they ration features.

It's a genius business strategy.

Um no. Long press the PDF and choose any app you want to open it.

The things that drove me nuts about iOS were small control issues that would creep up in everyday use. For example, opening PDF files. No big deal, right? Almost EVERY productivity or office app can open a PDF file. But therein lies the problem. In iOS, the OPEN WITH option only has room for about eight apps, and they appear in the order you have installed them with the most recent first. Needless to say, with iOS, Apple knows best, so you have no control over how this list is sorted or populated. This means that if you have a go-to app for document viewing (Goodreader is awesome on iOS), it gets pushed down the list as other apps are installed. Once it's off the list of eight, the ONLY way you can get it back on is to delete the app and reinstall it. How ridiculous is that?

In Android, I get a full list of apps compatible with the file type until I decide to limit it to a default of MY choice. And if I decide I want to change that default choice later on? No problem.

That's just one example. The glitches are scattered all across iOS where there is no viable workaround.

File browser
Multitasking
4g
Large screen
Swap battery
Sd card
More intuitive controls and ui with the back and menu buttons
Alternate keyboard and home screens
The first two and the last two are wrong. I have no idea where people get the idea iOS doesn't have true multitasking. The iPhone 5 dues out shortly will have 4g. Apple didn't rush to put the first power hungry and huge LTE chips in their phones.
iPads have LTE btw. Month to month contracts at Apples insistence.

That's not normal and you should know that. Android phones are just now getting the same battery life as iPhones and only a few of the newest android phones.



What I can do with my S3 that my iPhone couldn't do is have my S3 on WiFi with no apps running and know for sure that even with no usage that my S3 will drop about 25% with no usage within about 2 hours.

My iPhone definitely couldn't do this...lmaooo!!!

Def the expandable memory is greatly overlooked.
Not to mention having micro sub port for connection.
Flash
Flash
Oh, and did I mention flash?

The Apple dock connector provides far more capability.
Did you mention flash for mobile has been discontinued by Adobe because they admitted the could never get it to work right? I believe you did not.
 
There's no trigger in a dock other than power. So, Tasker would have no way to differentiate between car and home. Something that I saw someone else use was a BT connection, but I don't use BT.

slap an nfc sticker on that dock! boom, trigger :D but then, SU said he doesnt see any use in them, so never mind :rolleyes:
 
Show IPhone owners what features the IPhone 5 might have if Apple can figure out how to copy them.

That is amusing since Android copied their entire interface from apple. Look at android before and after the iPhone.

snookie, for the love of all that is good and holy, multi-quote.
id respond to some of the things you pointed out, but you made this thread such a mess, im not going to even bother...

You aren't able to.

If you are going to post that the iPhone doesn't do this or that at least look it up instead of just sayi g what you would like to believe. At least 80 % of the things posted here are wrong.
 
You aren't able to.

snookie, for the love of all that is good and holy, multi-quote.
id respond to some of the things you pointed out, but you made this thread such a mess, im not going to even bother...

You can just hit the "multi quote" buttons by each post, then hit reply at the bottom.

I'm just laughing reading some of these they are so far off.
Batteries really only matter if you are traveling and you can't take them on airplanes. iPhone's have had much better battery life making it less of a necessity. Some Android phones are coming sealed now too.
Wrong about voice commands
There are many browsers for iPhone including chrome and have been for a long time. You can make a browser other than safari the default on a jail broken iPhone but few people see the need to.
iTunes is far preferable to most people than the scope of what android offers but you can sync via wifi and iCloud which provides far more capability and better polish than anything google offers and it's free. I can't remember the lastt time I synced to iTunes.

I've worked in a hospital environment where communication was done fastest by cell phone - while my colleagues with iphones did usually have better battery life, there were on-call days where a dead battery was bound to happen. On those days I was glad to be able to swap in a fresh battery and not have to worry about getting calls about patients.


Heh. Thats just funny. Flash sucks on android and Adobe has given up and discontinued it.

It may suck, but it has always worked when I wanted it to and allowed me to view some webpages I don't think I would have been able otherwise.
 
To add in my 2 cents... disclosure: More experience with Android 2.2+, never rooted either of my phones, iOS exposure to a personal [gift haha] 4th gen iPod touch and girlfriend's iPhone 3GS and iPad... so I'm no expert by any means. Without considering rooting/jailbreaking (since that probably opens more options to people).

Widgets - I appreciated being able to see the weather, change my ringer, turn on the LED flash (as a flashlight), see my upcoming schedule, and start playing music all from the same screen without having to open anything. Being able to trigger my flashlight from the lockscreen was an even bigger plus in my book.

Keyboard - I didn't like the stock keyboard on my phone. Found a different one I did like. As far as I knew, I couldn't change the keyboard on my iPod.

Google Talk - I could never find a suitable iOS client for Google Talk (so if there's a suggestion...).

Personally, I'm more of a fan of the back and menu buttons. To me these feel more intuitive. I felt it made one-handed phone operation easier than hitting the on-screen back buttons in apps and such. My thumb would almost never have to move to the top part of the screen to do almost everything I wanted it to. I was glad in getting the S3 when I saw the menu button was retained (despite it being against ICS' ideology or whatever).

I have to admit, I was jealous of a friend who told me they jailbreaked (jailbroke?) their iphone just by plugging it into the computer, going to a website and hitting a "jailbreak now" button (or something like that), albeit incredulous about the security of such a method. Rooting options for my phones are never that simple.
 
What can I do that i-can't won't?

I can CHOOSE what manufacturer to buy from. I can CHOOSE how many processor cores I want in my phone. I can CHOOSE what carrier to buy from.

I could go on and on. You can't do any of that on the "other" platform, even if it is jailbroken! Plus, Jobs said anyone that jailbreaks their phone should go to jail and that it was "immoral".

I'll keep my morality intact and stick with my S3.
 
No you can't. Especially on a jail broken iPhone.

I'm talking about stock. You have to jailbreak an iPhone to get the same functionality that Android has out of the box.

You obviously have no experience with Apple to say that.

I have an iPad 2 and I had the first generation iPhone. My iPhone couldn't forward a text message or send a message to multiple people until several software updates later.

Apple has waited until version 6 to allow people to attach files to emails from within the email compose screen.

If that's not rationing features I don't know what is :p

If you are going to post that the iPhone doesn't do this or that at least look it up instead of just sayi g what you would like to believe. At least 80 % of the things posted here are wrong.

A lot of people are most likely talking about stock versions of both. For example, out of the box you can take pictures, answer phone calls or mute your alarm using your voice on the galaxy S3, but you'd have to jailbreak and void your warranty to do it on ios.
 
slap an nfc sticker on that dock! boom, trigger :D but then, SU said he doesnt see any use in them, so never mind :rolleyes:

I don't see any use for them. They're triggers. Hardware triggers. Why rely on peripheral hardware when it can all be done with software?!

Not sure why you're rolling your eyes at me during your mass trolling session. I didn't even mention your precious iPhone. Not once did I mention that it looked like shit or sounds like turd
 
With wifi direct, you are never without wifi ;)

Yeah, transferring a lot of files or big files will take longer, but I don't do that, so it's not a big deal for me.

I do this everyday, home wifi network transfers at 10mb/s, doesnt take long to copy 1GB plus files. :p
 
I don't see any use for them. They're triggers. Hardware triggers. Why rely on peripheral hardware when it can all be done with software?!

Normally I would agree, but there's nothing to differentiate one dock from another. For example, I might have a dock on my desk that I just want to use as a charger, but then have a music dock that I want to start Spotify/music player.

Tasker only differentiates between "car" and "desk" docks.

It's not like Bluetooth/WiFi where you can trigger things when connected to a certain one :p
 
I don't see any use for them. They're triggers. Hardware triggers. Why rely on peripheral hardware when it can all be done with software?!

Not sure why you're rolling your eyes at me during your mass trolling session. I didn't even mention your precious iPhone. Not once did I mention that it looked like shit or sounds like turd

whoa, whoa, just jokes man. besides, what trolling session? and WHAT iphone?? i think youve got me mixed up with this snookie's thousands of posts...
 
whoa, whoa, just jokes man. besides, what trolling session? and WHAT iphone?? i think youve got me mixed up with this snookie's thousands of posts...


You're right, I did. I'm sorry. That sort of comment is alright coming from you...

It does sound like turd though. The iphone.
 
no problemo. our names do unfortunately look slightly similar.

im with you all the way there. it is a shiny one, but, as they say, still a turd
 
Originally Posted by Mabashi
File browser
Multitasking
4g
Large screen
Swap battery
Sd card
More intuitive controls and ui with the back and menu buttons
Alternate keyboard and home screens

The first two and the last two are wrong. I have no idea where people get the idea iOS doesn't have true multitasking. The iPhone 5 dues out shortly will have 4g. Apple didn't rush to put the first power hungry and huge LTE chips in their phones.
iPads have LTE btw. Month to month contracts at Apples insistence.

Yes i know the next iphone will have 4g I have been enjoying the 4g speeds for about a year now and i've been wondering how iPhone people have been surviving without it since the technology was available before the iPhone 4s release. Yes 4g is power hungry but the Galaxy S 3 has the best battery life of any 4g device that i've seen so far. And you could always buy a spare battery (btw on your earlier comment, you can take spare batteries on airplanes, I've carried one on me for the past 2-3 years on many flights and no one told me I couldn't)

File Browser - Stock iPhones can't get a file browser, they can't see all their files (other than camera pictures) outside of the individual apps. I like being able to have a mp3 or video sitting on my phone and if someone else wants it, I could easily email it or bluetooth it over to a friend. Dealing with itunes to transfer is a impossible if the only place you have the file is on your phone since iTunes is very restrictive about pulling videos or music off the phone and since you can only sync the devide with one computer (also if you want to switch computers, you have to wipe the phone). You'd have to download some 3rd party software (not all of them free) to transfer the file to the computer then to the other person's phone.

Multitasking - stock iPhones do not have full multitasking. They have a few limited multitasking API's such as streaming music. But for example, if you had a 3rd party app (not itunes or app store) that was downloading a video or something else for you, if you switched away from that app, the download would pause until you go back to it. Also there is no way that stock iPhones have the capability to multitask and do things like Tasker can with the limited API's.

More intuitive controls and ui with the back and menu buttons- This is really personal preference but without a dedicated back button and menu button, its really up to the developer's to put them on so its not completely consistent as to where they are for every app. Like in games the pause button with the settings can be placed in different spots (top left corner, top right corner, 2 finger gestures, etc.) but with the hardware button its always consistent.

Alternate keyboard and home screens - Stock iPhones don't have access to swype or to change they keyboard to anything else like customizing the appearance with go keyboards. By home screens, I meant launchers. Stock iPhones can't modify the launcher and replace it like android can. Androids could use launchers to emulate iPhones or Windows Phone 7s if they waned to. Or they could provide cooler effects like SPB Shell 3d or make it easier for people who are vision impaired with BIG Launcher
 
Back
Top Bottom