if i read the OP's post correctly he doesn't really care for 3G, but wants to use at least EDGE/GPRS service. since all phones i have used fall back to at least EDGE, i would like to assume the service is available, although if AT&T has some 'requirement' that a phone must support 3G by default, similar to how Verizon has a 'requirement' that a phone must be at least e-911 compatible, then the only means to bypass this restriction is to use a pre-paid MVNO that has no such requirement but still uses the same towers. if he wants to use AT&T the Net10/StraightTalk BYOP plan may be the way to go, and if he prefers Verizon Page Plus is a way out. although last i heard, Page Plus does not yet support data (they are mostly for those retro geeks who still use a Motorola StarTAC these days) however if all the OP wants is wifi and cellular only, this may be a preferred way out.