My opinion the Galaxy Tab 10.1 is the ipad killer. Asus rules too with all the features. Im huge Asus fan, at least as far as my computer hardware. Can't wait to plug my 128GB Flash Drive - thumb drive - into the GT 10.1 or card reader. Plug my camera into it and dump my pictures (I don't use online storage/services) HTC will have a nice 10" tab (I love sense) My opinion you get lot more with HTC sense than you think you do. Lets say everything worked on the Xoom right now I would still put it down on the list around 5th or worse, Just because of the display.
-
After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.
Xoom vs Galaxy tab 10.1
- Thread starter jacobj9
- Start date
That's why Apple is filing gazillion lawsuits on a weekly basis to try to stop Samsung from selling the device. The folks at Cupertino are very nervous and scared right now.
Jore
Android Enthusiast
The ipad was cool, but nothing stays #1 forever. Apple is just realizing that right now and scared.
I am not sure it is this way at all Best Buys (probably is), but at our store the first tablet display you come to is the Samsung one. It is the first computer related display at all. The Apple one is the LAST ONE!!! It is practically on top of the TV area of the store. There is also a dedicated Samsung rep on site all weekend long and Apple is on their own. Apple's arrogance might just give them a swift kick this time 
scanman
Well-Known Member
Huh??
Maybe should have read...
"The xoom is a second rate product compared to the Tab 10. Its (Samsung Galaxy 10.1 tablet) completely out classes my the xoom."
..I dunno, maybe I'm reading it wrong?
Jore
Android Enthusiast
At my best buy the tab is kind of off away from the PC section. Right in the middle of the PC section however is the HP Touchpad, and they must have like 8 demos out on an island by themselves. The ipads are the furthest away however the display area is alot cleaner with all kinds of flyers/info/etc. The Samsung Tab 10.1 is sort of hidden behind the eye catching display of the apple PC's, along with the Xoom. But you know what, I was at best buy yesterday and noticed most of the accessories for the tab 10.1 are gone.
Also I picked up the xoom for the first time yesterday...I did not realize how thick and heavier the thing is compared to the tab 10.1. But then again, the xoom has all the ports the tab 10.1 doesn't have.
Also I picked up the xoom for the first time yesterday...I did not realize how thick and heavier the thing is compared to the tab 10.1. But then again, the xoom has all the ports the tab 10.1 doesn't have.
That's funny
Perhaps Moto should market their tablet that way: "You can build bicep while surfing the net", ha ha.I'm sorry, I find the weight argument to be absolutely ridiculous. Are we all losing muscle mass at a rate that holding/hauling 1.5lbs of tablet is a problem? How did our grandparents manage it when they had to carry around 15lbs typewriters. 
On topic, the Xoom looks and feels better built than the Galaxy. More metal, less plastic = quality feel.
The Xoom weights 1.6lbs and the Galaxy weights 1.32lbs so if 0.28lbs is enough to hold you back, the Galaxy is the tablet for you (it is also slightly thinner).
On the screen, I have not noticed any difference, but some people swear the Galaxy has a crispier image than the Xoom. The Xoom's screen is supposedly made of an extra-tough glass - some say that's why it's difficult to find screen protectors, because Motorola thinks you won't need one.
If a tablet camera is important for you, the Xoom has a 5MP back camera while the Galaxy has a 3MP camera, but both take pictures of mediocre quality when compared even to an old 5MP camera (and you will look silly lifting up your tablet to take a photo of the Statue of Liberty or something).
Both have the same processors; memory depends on how much money you spend; GPS, Wi-Fi, BlueTooth, etc...
The Galaxy suffers from a deplorable lack of ports, but with that said, half the Xoom's ports are still pending software updates from Motorola to work as they are supposed to, so even though you get MicroSD Card, MicroUSB and MicroHDMI with the Xoom, the MicroSD Card is non-functiona, it has been due for an update that will turn it on since March, the USB is good for nothing more than connecting the tablet to your computer to transfer files, or to your camera if it supports the proper protocol - oh and you need an adapter for that. Motorola says in the future we could maybe expect the USB to have Mass Storage capabilities (to plug in an external HD, for example), but there is no official word on it. So while the Xoom has a bunch of ports, they aren't what they seem. but eventually, the Xoom will have a MicroSD slot (up to 32GB) and maybe a proper USB port.
While the Galaxy doesn't have an USB port, an optional USB adapter / connection kit offers an adapter to allow USB thumb drives to plug in to the tablet.
I absolutely love the Xoom, but it is disappointing that the things that would make it stand out are still works-in-progress. It is a pretty close call, but I would recommend the Galaxy because at least you won't be angry at Motorola for selling you a very expensive "to be continued..." product.
If waiting is no problem for you, go for the Xoom!
On topic, the Xoom looks and feels better built than the Galaxy. More metal, less plastic = quality feel.
The Xoom weights 1.6lbs and the Galaxy weights 1.32lbs so if 0.28lbs is enough to hold you back, the Galaxy is the tablet for you (it is also slightly thinner).
On the screen, I have not noticed any difference, but some people swear the Galaxy has a crispier image than the Xoom. The Xoom's screen is supposedly made of an extra-tough glass - some say that's why it's difficult to find screen protectors, because Motorola thinks you won't need one.
If a tablet camera is important for you, the Xoom has a 5MP back camera while the Galaxy has a 3MP camera, but both take pictures of mediocre quality when compared even to an old 5MP camera (and you will look silly lifting up your tablet to take a photo of the Statue of Liberty or something).
Both have the same processors; memory depends on how much money you spend; GPS, Wi-Fi, BlueTooth, etc...
The Galaxy suffers from a deplorable lack of ports, but with that said, half the Xoom's ports are still pending software updates from Motorola to work as they are supposed to, so even though you get MicroSD Card, MicroUSB and MicroHDMI with the Xoom, the MicroSD Card is non-functiona, it has been due for an update that will turn it on since March, the USB is good for nothing more than connecting the tablet to your computer to transfer files, or to your camera if it supports the proper protocol - oh and you need an adapter for that. Motorola says in the future we could maybe expect the USB to have Mass Storage capabilities (to plug in an external HD, for example), but there is no official word on it. So while the Xoom has a bunch of ports, they aren't what they seem. but eventually, the Xoom will have a MicroSD slot (up to 32GB) and maybe a proper USB port.
While the Galaxy doesn't have an USB port, an optional USB adapter / connection kit offers an adapter to allow USB thumb drives to plug in to the tablet.
I absolutely love the Xoom, but it is disappointing that the things that would make it stand out are still works-in-progress. It is a pretty close call, but I would recommend the Galaxy because at least you won't be angry at Motorola for selling you a very expensive "to be continued..." product.
If waiting is no problem for you, go for the Xoom!
MutantCheese
Android Expert
Hmmm, your first post is argumentative....not a good start
My last post was a joke. But seriously, in this stage and age, mobile device buyers are becoming very FASHION CONSCIOUS. While people on this discussion forum are very focus on specs...naturally, the vast majority of the consumers out there do not split hair on specs. Instead, they are buying mobile devices primarily based on style and look.
The one and only reason why Apple has been so successful is because they understand that the vast majority of the consumers are not geeks but fashion conscious people. So far, Samsung is the only Android vendor that understands this (and I think HTC is beginning to understand this as well, but Motorola is still stuck in the geek world) and it is reflected on their products. And that's why the Galaxy S outsold any other Android smart phone line on this planet.
Just one look at the Galaxy Tab 10.1 and you will fall in love with it. On the other hand, the Xoom just does not give you such feeling. It gives you the feeling that it is just another tablet which can be lost easily in the crowd.
Hope this helps.
But seriously, in this stage and age, mobile device buyers are becoming very FASHION CONSCIOUS. While people on this discussion forum are very focus on specs...naturally, the vast majority of the consumers out there do not split hair on specs. Instead, they are buying mobile devices primarily based on style and look.The one and only reason why Apple has been so successful is because they understand that the vast majority of the consumers are not geeks but fashion conscious people. So far, Samsung is the only Android vendor that understands this (and I think HTC is beginning to understand this as well, but Motorola is still stuck in the geek world) and it is reflected on their products. And that's why the Galaxy S outsold any other Android smart phone line on this planet.
Just one look at the Galaxy Tab 10.1 and you will fall in love with it. On the other hand, the Xoom just does not give you such feeling. It gives you the feeling that it is just another tablet which can be lost easily in the crowd.
Hope this helps.
Jore
Android Enthusiast
Everyone can argue which is better and at the end of the day its what the buyer prefers. This almost sounds like a ipad vs tab thread. He chose to buy the xoom because its what he wanted. We are all on the same team here and lets not forget who the enemy is......the Ipad 2....
I personally went with the tab 10.1 because of the thinness, screen, and am also a current owner of the original tab which is awesome as well, experience and reputation. I didn't go with the Xoom because this is the first tablet by Motorola, didn't know what to expect from them down the road. Which is why I steered away from the HTC flyer, the View, Touchpad, etc. Samsung has been in the tablet game so the Tab 10.1 had some experience built into it. Ports played no part in my decision as I hardly ever cared about that on the original tab. I'm really looking forward to the touchwiz update.
Again..this is me.
I personally went with the tab 10.1 because of the thinness, screen, and am also a current owner of the original tab which is awesome as well, experience and reputation. I didn't go with the Xoom because this is the first tablet by Motorola, didn't know what to expect from them down the road. Which is why I steered away from the HTC flyer, the View, Touchpad, etc. Samsung has been in the tablet game so the Tab 10.1 had some experience built into it. Ports played no part in my decision as I hardly ever cared about that on the original tab. I'm really looking forward to the touchwiz update.
Again..this is me.
I absolutely agree with you, substring. For everyday consumers, in the end what matters is how fashionable their tablets are.
And I apologize if my view on weight sounds argumentative, that was not the intention. But when I was shopping for tablets, more often than not a tablet being a couple of grams lighter than another was pointed out as a defining winning factor as why that tablet was better, and like I said, I find that ridiculous.
If you meant other parts of my post were argumentative, well, this is an X vs. Y thread. People are going to compare the two and point out what the rotten bits are.
And I apologize if my view on weight sounds argumentative, that was not the intention. But when I was shopping for tablets, more often than not a tablet being a couple of grams lighter than another was pointed out as a defining winning factor as why that tablet was better, and like I said, I find that ridiculous.
If you meant other parts of my post were argumentative, well, this is an X vs. Y thread. People are going to compare the two and point out what the rotten bits are.
krouget
Android Enthusiast
I'd have to agree in that it's a close call between the two.
After spending some time with the Galaxy Tab 10.1, I feel the difference mainly comes down to whether or not you need SD and HDMI support, and what may be faster updates (gray area, here). In most other areas, I'd give the edge to the Glaxay Tab, if I had to recommend one.
Though it's not as dramatic as I feel some would suggest, the display seems more vibrant at max brightness, it is lighter/thinner, and I also like the option of haptic feedback. I feel the Xoom carries its weight differently, especially when holding with one hand, but it's plenty bearable (which includes the fact that mine usually wears a case). I didn't get the impression that the 10.1 was cheap, either...it felt appropriate enough. Even though the Xoom does feel more solid, it doesn't necessarily mean it's better built-- in a nutshell, I'd be concerned with dropping either, from even a few feet.
So again, I can see a case being made for either tablet, but there isn't much to envy from either end, once you get past the primary differences. Both are superb, with a slight nod going to the Galaxy Tab as an all-around device. I could just as easily own one and be happy.
clb2196
Android Enthusiast
I have a Xoom. I love it, I really do. But I plan on selling it and getting a SGT 10.1 as soon as te 4G one is out. IMO, the weight really makes a difference to me. It does get awakward holding it for a while, especially in portrait, where I always feel like it's going to flip forward and hit me in the face lol. If it doesn't make a difference to some people, that's cool, and it wasn't enough for me not to buy the Xoom anyway, but it's more than enough to make me willing to switch.
I love these debates. I'll add my .02...
We can see by the development of the first MaxiPad, err...iPad... that an intimate experience with a personal screen was the goal. Not expand-ability or laptop replacement. With the 2nd generation iPad, the only 2 changes were the CPU & SIZE. (And magnets... I know I know)... Because they stuck with their original intent of just single screen, single user application.
Moving to HoneyComb, which is very much bridging the gap between Tab/Phone OS to Full OS, the needs become inflated. Does any iPad user out there care that their screen resolution is less than ours? NO, they all went to the Apple store, picked up the iPad and clicked the Facebook App and said "I'll take it".
What Samsung has done is put the Apple form factor (Thin & Light)... again, only one of the 2 upgrades to the iPad showing it's a major factor among purchasers and added better resolution, additional features (GPS) and kept the price point where it belonged. It's the one I just chose after much research and testing.
The Xoom is a 1st gen Android tablet at best. I've used it a lot and I swear there's a netbook's keyboard stuffed in back proving all they did was fold a netbook on itself. It's far too thick and heavy to be considered 2nd gen.
So, in closing, for the main point of tablet which is portability single user applications, the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 is the best on the market right now. I'm sure there will be competitors but for now, the others squeezed too much into their devices with the intent to make a 'Do All Appliance' and that's not what tablets are for.
We can see by the development of the first MaxiPad, err...iPad... that an intimate experience with a personal screen was the goal. Not expand-ability or laptop replacement. With the 2nd generation iPad, the only 2 changes were the CPU & SIZE. (And magnets... I know I know)... Because they stuck with their original intent of just single screen, single user application.
Moving to HoneyComb, which is very much bridging the gap between Tab/Phone OS to Full OS, the needs become inflated. Does any iPad user out there care that their screen resolution is less than ours? NO, they all went to the Apple store, picked up the iPad and clicked the Facebook App and said "I'll take it".
What Samsung has done is put the Apple form factor (Thin & Light)... again, only one of the 2 upgrades to the iPad showing it's a major factor among purchasers and added better resolution, additional features (GPS) and kept the price point where it belonged. It's the one I just chose after much research and testing.
The Xoom is a 1st gen Android tablet at best. I've used it a lot and I swear there's a netbook's keyboard stuffed in back proving all they did was fold a netbook on itself. It's far too thick and heavy to be considered 2nd gen.
So, in closing, for the main point of tablet which is portability single user applications, the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 is the best on the market right now. I'm sure there will be competitors but for now, the others squeezed too much into their devices with the intent to make a 'Do All Appliance' and that's not what tablets are for.
techrider62
Android Enthusiast
So because the tab 10.1 is so similar to the iPad it's the best.The other tab are not trying to be the iPad and all the android tab's out right are first gen.
lens pirate
Member
With as many nice smooth elegant options for moving files on and off of the SGT 10 I see ports as a non-issue. There for its SGT 10 for the win.
techrider62
Android Enthusiast
I have purchased four tablets for side by side comparison. ASUS Transformer, iPad2, Galaxy 10.1, Xoom. I have been playing with them for a few days now and here are my thoughts.
iPad2 is the best of the bunch over all with the most apps and best size to weight ratio. It works equally as well in portrait and landscape modes. Also the OS is a bit smoother. Screen is not the highest resolution but looks the best in terms of colors and brightness. I would say Galaxy is the 2nd best overall and the one I am staying with. Xoom has lots of features but just too heavy and the screen does not look as good as the others. Transformer has the features of the Xoom with excellent screen, it would be my 2nd choice but again the Galaxy wins for size and weight. Hope this helps.
Hi, my first posting on Galaxy Tab forum. I'm looking to get 10" android tablet and Tab 10.1 seems like a good one. I considered 4G LTE verizon one but after reading bluetooth phone connection thread, WiFi only should be fine for me.
My only concern is media connectivity through USB and HDMI. Is that possible with Tab 10.1? Does it require optional adapter/cable?
My only concern is media connectivity through USB and HDMI. Is that possible with Tab 10.1? Does it require optional adapter/cable?