I'm seeing the same type of results when comparing mine and my wife's S3 to our previous phones...the DX.
-
After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.
Verizon GS3 signal reception thread
- Thread starter rushmore
- Start date
-
- Tags
- samsung galaxy s3
I'm seeing the same type of results when comparing mine and my wife's S3 to our previous phones...the DX.
This sounds more likely; i doubt prl data is actually on the sim; typically the sim just contains a code that can be used to identify the user for authentication. If it containted prl data (I know i raised this as a possibility) then you would have to frequently update your sim as the network changes. Then again not too many people have 'old' smart phones 
Didn't have a great day coming back from Boston (reception wise). We stopped at a rest stop on the Connecticut Tpk and I noticed I only had 1X. Of course I grabbed my wife's IPhone and she had 3G. DAMN!
Not satisfied, I tried pulling up the same website and hers got it, though not particularly fast, and I got the dreaded "no connectivity" message. This was the first time the differences were that significant.
We sat down at a table closer to a window and she maintained her 3G while I was switching between 1X and 3G. At times my connection speed matched hers, but generally at this location the IPhone was faster with no data drops.
OTOH, while we were driving prior to arriving at the rest stop, my wife was streaming a local radio station on TuneIn Radio. She was dropping the stream fairly regularly and I kidded her that she had a bad phone. We tried the S3 and it didn't drop the stream as long as I was on the App. She thought it was just coincidence in that we may have hit a bad signal area while she was connected. To see if that was the case, we had both phones running the App and hers still dropped the stream while mine maintained it.
So what does all this prove? Again, it seem inescapable, comparing two phones is so location dependent even when it appears they're getting the same signal. It seems at one location phone A may do better than phone B and at another location the results might do a 180. Go figure. Multipath rejection? Possibly.
Not satisfied, I tried pulling up the same website and hers got it, though not particularly fast, and I got the dreaded "no connectivity" message. This was the first time the differences were that significant.
We sat down at a table closer to a window and she maintained her 3G while I was switching between 1X and 3G. At times my connection speed matched hers, but generally at this location the IPhone was faster with no data drops.
OTOH, while we were driving prior to arriving at the rest stop, my wife was streaming a local radio station on TuneIn Radio. She was dropping the stream fairly regularly and I kidded her that she had a bad phone. We tried the S3 and it didn't drop the stream as long as I was on the App. She thought it was just coincidence in that we may have hit a bad signal area while she was connected. To see if that was the case, we had both phones running the App and hers still dropped the stream while mine maintained it.
So what does all this prove? Again, it seem inescapable, comparing two phones is so location dependent even when it appears they're getting the same signal. It seems at one location phone A may do better than phone B and at another location the results might do a 180. Go figure. Multipath rejection? Possibly.
rushmore
Extreme Android User
Same here, since see no practical difference in signal comparing the GS3 with Droid 3 and Razr.
I actually have 4G in places I never even had 3G with the Razr Maxx. Couldn't believe my eyes when I same the 4G symbol on the notification bar. Granted it was like -107dbm but hey it was still moving data!!
Trent Reznor
Android Expert
Soo.... I think I either have the only Gnex with good radios, a poor GS3, or sim card issues.
My Gnex is consistently showing better dBm than my GS3 at home. My GS3 at work today was struggling to hold 3g in places that I previously had no issues with my Gnex
I am using the sim card from my Gnex in the GS3. When I swap sim cards (use my fiancees that came with GS3 and was originally activated in GS3) I get faster ping's and faster speedtest results. Guess I'll make a stop at VZW tomorrow.
My Gnex is consistently showing better dBm than my GS3 at home. My GS3 at work today was struggling to hold 3g in places that I previously had no issues with my Gnex
I am using the sim card from my Gnex in the GS3. When I swap sim cards (use my fiancees that came with GS3 and was originally activated in GS3) I get faster ping's and faster speedtest results. Guess I'll make a stop at VZW tomorrow.
M
Member 536573
Guest
Soo.... I think I either have the only Gnex with good radios, a poor GS3, or sim card issues.
My Gnex is consistently showing better dBm than my GS3 at home. My GS3 at work today was struggling to hold 3g in places that I previously had no issues with my Gnex
I am using the sim card from my Gnex in the GS3. When I swap sim cards (use my fiancees that came with GS3 and was originally activated in GS3) I get faster ping's and faster speedtest results. Guess I'll make a stop at VZW tomorrow.
If it was just today don't get to concerned b/c folks were reporting issues w/ 4G today throughout the country.
http://androidforums.com/samsung-ga...-sudden-loss-4g-service-entirely-verizon.html
Trent Reznor
Android Expert
Just now.... still doesn't explain why Gnex is performing better and I always only get 3g at work. Other than the one way audio issue my Gnex performs better.
wysilverado
Newbie
After following this thread and worrying about having signal issues like I had with the 2 GN I tried, I stopped by Verizon to buy a Razr Maxx before a 5000 mile Road Trip to NY and back .While there the Verizon Gal who is a friend set a G3 in front of Me ...... After drooling I decided to take it and try it for a few days before We leave. Our Steel Shop is a Signal dead zone,I've had many more Phone fail the Signal test than pass it there . Surprisingly the G3 was flawless,better than My iPhone4 ,maybe better than my current 4s which would put it in Razr/Razr Maxx territory . BTW,my 2 GN's I tried would not even hold a call in our shop.
I've had a iphone4/4s since the hit Verizon with a few stints with Razr/Razr Maxx, Rezound,& 2 Galaxy Nexus' The Maxx was my Favorite because of reception and Battery but the screen was average and camera sucked.The nexus was sweet but reception was awful . I love My iPhones ,We have 9 lines......2 feature phones, 6 iPhones and now a G3.I'm in love with the G3 ,at least til the iphone5 ,maybe longer! Try the G3 for sure before you get scared off by signal issues like I almost did!
I've had a iphone4/4s since the hit Verizon with a few stints with Razr/Razr Maxx, Rezound,& 2 Galaxy Nexus' The Maxx was my Favorite because of reception and Battery but the screen was average and camera sucked.The nexus was sweet but reception was awful . I love My iPhones ,We have 9 lines......2 feature phones, 6 iPhones and now a G3.I'm in love with the G3 ,at least til the iphone5 ,maybe longer! Try the G3 for sure before you get scared off by signal issues like I almost did!
rushmore
Extreme Android User
It seems weird some are having issues with the GS3, but even the Razr had some report dings too. Like some other positive reception reports, the GS3 picks up strong 4G signal in our stairwell at work that goes to the basesment. GS3 works better there than the Razr did. Same for other weak areas where the Razr would lose signal. The GS3 might bounce from 4G to 3G, but has a signal. The Razr would be 3G and then 1X.
Not saying the GS3 is really better, since still too early. Must stay aware of the new device pixie dust.
Seems to be settling on the Razr is a little better than the GS3 for 3G performance and the GS3 is better for 4G performance. Net is a wash for me, since call coverage appear the same.
As far as the other features besides phone radios, the GS3 is far better than the Razr. No comparison, IMO.
For me, the GS3 is the first device I can really say is an all-in-one system.
Not saying the GS3 is really better, since still too early. Must stay aware of the new device pixie dust.
Seems to be settling on the Razr is a little better than the GS3 for 3G performance and the GS3 is better for 4G performance. Net is a wash for me, since call coverage appear the same.
As far as the other features besides phone radios, the GS3 is far better than the Razr. No comparison, IMO.
For me, the GS3 is the first device I can really say is an all-in-one system.
wysilverado
Newbie
The wi-fi reception is not as good as a Maxx,or my iPhones .Not horrible just noticeably weaker.
thelber
Newbie
Well so far a day after getting a replacement sim my data connection has been greatly improved. I haven't got any drops in my data even with the phone reading 1 bar of signal in locations where before I couldn't get a data connection. Whether it be the actual sim or the act of having a new sim activated it has seemed to help in my situation.
Very happy with the performance of this phone now so up on eBay goes my Razr Maxx!
Very happy with the performance of this phone now so up on eBay goes my Razr Maxx!
I went from the Droid X to the S3 and my reception is a hundred times worse. My nearest tower is just across my neighborhood. I should have constant 3g reception. But i connect to it on my S3 every once in awhile (2 or 3 bars max) and it disconects and goes back to 1x. I have in 2 days only been able to load 2 web pages over 3g. i have to use wifi in order to do anything data wise. and mms takes forever with my reception.
SamMax
Android Expert
So far I am still very happy with my S3 but I have had a couple instances where I have been muted according to the other party I have been talking with. I hung up and and redialed and that seemed to fix the issue...I am going to have to see if that was a fluke or if there's something to it.
You shouldn't dial *228 from a Verizon 4G phone with a SIM card. You'll have to go and have your SIM replaced to get your 4G back.
Same here. I call support and I am getting a replacement. Seems to be a known issue based on the techs comments....and it's killing my battery!
http://androidforums.com/showpost.php?p=4690365
Same with me initially. Right near a tower but wasn't getting 3g at all. Had to go to settings and switch on data roaming and unchecked and recheck Use Packet Data. 3g instantly showed up strong and has been working ever since. Several days later I was able to switch it back to Deny Data Roaming access and continued to get 3g. Clearly my new S3 wasn't authorized to use towers it should have been. However, don't do a *228. If you do, you'll brick your sim and you won't get 3g at all.
The first CSR wanted to replace my phone too. I'm glad I spoke to another one who was more knowledgeable and figured out what was really going on and how to fix it.