• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Help S4 motherboard swap to another S4 (same model)

Albert00

Lurker
Hello

I was just wondering, Is it possible to swap 2 motherboards from two exact S4 ?
The reason I'm asking this is that I have broken my current Verizon S4 glass ...
BUT I have an my old S4 that had a motherboard problem (that's why I changed phone in the firs place) and this one is in perfect state (no broken glass etc...)

SO I was wondering maybe I can take out the motherboard of my broken Glass S4 and put it in my old non broken glass S4?
Is this going to work ?

ps: Also is all the internal files (Os, internal memeory etc..) on the motherboard ?

Thanks!!!
 
1) Yes, but doing it yourself will probably end in your breaking something, requiring fixing it, which will end in your breaking something else, over and over, until you've spent more than a new S4 would cost.

Bringing it to a shop with an experienced tech would cost you something, but would result in a working phone.

2) Yes.
 
Advising people not to fix their phones themselves is one of Rukbat's favourite topics but I think he is right. I have seen a lot of threads here and elsewhere from people who have tried to fix their phone (usually replacing the screen) and ended up doing expensive damage.

If you are experienced working with modern smartphones, go ahead but if you are not, I would really think twice before risking doing it yourself. The innards are fiddly and tiny and often glued together. They are not easy to work on.
 
Advising people not to fix their phones themselves is one of Rukbat's favourite topics but I think he is right. I have seen a lot of threads here and elsewhere from people who have tried to fix their phone (usually replacing the screen) and ended up doing expensive damage.

If you are experienced working with modern smartphones
My take (as someone who spent years repairing them) is that anyone who has enough experience to repair one without breaking it wouldn't be asking questions here. I left the business a little before Android came out, so there are plenty of times I hit a glitch due to not being that experienced with Android. (By "not that experienced" I mean that I've never modified a copy of Android source and recompiled it myself, something I've done countless times with Linux.) But I don't post a question, I have enough experience to find the answer or, if no one else has ever experienced what I have, to bring the phone to someone who does. (Since I own Samsung phones t the moment, I head for Best Buy or my carrier, depending on the problem. My only working non-Samsung, a Motorola V551, isn't worth repairing, because I can probably find an equivalent on Craig's List for $10. And my Motorola Bricks and Startacs can't be used any more [but I'm sentimental], so I just keep them as reminders of a much earlier time.)

I figure that anyone asking how to replace a motherboard has never opened a phone before (it's pretty apparent to anyone who's worked on phones, but not the particular one he's working on now, where the motherboard is, which connectors have to be removed to swap it out and which screws have to be removed), so he's never unclipped a tiny ribbon connector, so he's asking for trouble. (I haven't worked on anything smaller than pressing the keys on my keyboard in a few years because I started developing cataracts, and if you can't read 4 point type without glasses or squinting, you have no business working on microelectronics. One cataract is now out, the other one comes out in 3 weeks, then there's about a month of healing before my vision will be good enough that a magnifier will give me the vision I need to see some of the components in a modern cellphone. Then we'll see whether my hands are still steady enough to work on one [which I doubt, but we'll see]. The last soldering job I did might pass in any electronics shop course, but not if I were the instructor. It worked, but out of 20 pins, I don't think the solder looked the same on any two of them. It should look identical on all of them.)

The same reasoning goes for people asking how to replace a screen or, worse, the glass on the screen. I've trained techs to do that sort of work for me. It takes the best tech a few broken screens before he can remove the broken glass and replace it without damaging anything. (Which is why good shops keep unrepairable phones in cartons in the back room. They're for techs to break when they're learning how not to break customers' phones.)

I have a few hot buttons when it comes to cellphones - this is one of them. It's usually cheaper to take the phone in for repair the first time, than after you've broken a few things. (One of my other buttons is how to get around the block on a stolen phone. This is androidforums, not Thieves' School. Buying a $600 phone in perfect working condition for $100 doesn't seem to raise any questions in the minds of a lot of people these days.)
 
I totally agree with what you said.

But I want to clarify that I didn't ask "How to replace a motherboard" but
"Is this gonna work?".

I didn't specify but I'm a Senior software engineer who has had plenty of soldering courses, hardware courses etc.... I have more than once built a PC from scratch etc...

I just never did anything with phones... So before breaking everything because "maybe" "maybeee" replacing motherboard on a phone wouldn't have worked ? Not compatible?? (IMEI etc...) .. ??

That is why I preferred to asked more experienced people in this domain..

And yes you are right, I have never opened a phone before, and that would have have been very stupid from me to attempt such a job without knowing anything..

But thank's to Mr. Youtube there is plentyyyy of HD videos that explain EXACTLY which clip to remove etc.....
Very very helpful... Once I had my phoned opened it took me 5 minute to orientated myself in there. (And yes I was suprised by how SMALL everything is in there)

But yes again I agree with you, better to advise people no to do this as without any knowledge, it is a guaranteed fail..

Oh by the way: I have replaced the motherboard successfully this Sunday with calm and everything is working fine :smokingsomb:

Thanks again
 
Glad it worked out for you. We see so many "now what do I do" posts here, as the first post, after someone tried to fix a phone without asking, watching videos, etc.
 
Hi,
I am one proud owner of the Canadian Rogers Galaxy S4 I337m and unfortunatly softbricked it till the point that Odin fails to load the stock android 4.4.2 firmware in it...
now it only boot on download mode and/or custom rom. I am Swapping the motherboard with an U.S. AT&T I337 one for usage in the U.S. for work.

My Questions is : Will It work? Both phones are identical except for the LTE network band, chip and modem which are included in the motherboard. On the Hardware side, is there any other parts that need to be replaced beside the motherboard?

Thank you
 
Back
Top Bottom