With all the phones Samsung sells they should have some control. Apple does. I do not believe it is 100% AT&T. When I check out the gingerbread question on the Samsung site, they have given the standard line on hundreds of questions on the subject. I think everyone has simply dropped any consideration for updates to the Captivate as its technoolgy is so far behind the current phones. There is no money in it to support it and try to make it a satisfactory experience. As it is now, the phone is not very good unless you want to root it and and start dealing with a different set of issues.