I had the opportunity to look at the Green Mountain Daniel Boone today. Naturally it came home with me.
I decided that I'll take my five year old Traeger pellet grill to the cabin and leave the Danny Boone on my patio. I'm not certain exactly what's up with the Traeger but it tops out at around 360°. That's perfectly fine for smoking but since my JennAir grill is in poor repair I either needed another grill or a smoker that will get hot enough to grill a steak.
The Daniel Boone will top out at over 550° and fill that need. So.. new home smoker and old smoker for the cabin.
My first impressions of the Daniel Boone:
It seems well constructed but I'm certain I'll miss the cabinet storage that the Traeger supplied. It was very easy to assemble.
It's start/smoke temp is 150° vs the Traeger's 80°. It took about the same amount of time to get to and maintain the low temp on both smokers. The Daniel Boone has a digital controller and readout.
It took ten minutes to reach 550° which seemed reasonable. I ran it that hot for ten minutes then turned it back down to 150°. It took ten minutes for it to fall back to start temp. The heat dispersal metal in the Daniel Boone is far superior to that of the Traeger in construction and gauge. It came with a meat probe that reads out on the controller. The hopper has a quick dump feature so that you can change pellet flavors if you care to. The cooking grates are stainless steel but are not large diameter rods. I can see burgers wanting to wrap around them.. we'll see. It has a burn pot cleaning cycle that it initiates on shut down. It first burns out the existing pellets then the fan goes to high and puffs out the ashes. which should prove to be a nice feature. The side shelf seems adequate but not extremely robust. The Traeger had two side shelves that were very sturdy. The lid on the Daniel Boone and it's hinges seem a little weak to me. I think they will last without abuse but there will be no throwing back the lid for it might just keep on going.
To sum up, I think the Daniel Boone is a lot of pellet smoker/grill for $529. I paid far more for my Traeger but that was five years ago. It's design is good and it's features seem to have been well thought out. I've not shopped smokers for half a decade so they all might have progressed since I last purchased. I will have to use it for a while before I recommend it but my initial take on it is that it's going to be a winner.