So i just tried to return a triumph with a small crack in the screen and was told that cracked screens are not covered in the black tie protection plan. DOes anyone know if this is true? If it is what should I do?
Best Buy Mobile employee here.
Wow. Cracked screen is absolutely covered by Black Tie Protection. If anyone in Best Buy tells you otherwise, raise hell up the chain until you get your service.
I see all kinds of misunderstandings in this thread (which may of course come from Best Buy employee confusion, too, when they explained things) so let me see if I can briefly clear up a few key points.
1. Black Tie Protection for your phone covers darned near everything except LOSS, THEFT, or FULL IMMERSION. I have even seen full immersion cases replaced when the phone was grabbed quickly out of the water; the phone is opened up and replacement is determined on a case-by-case basis.
2. Black Tie Protection IS NOT INSURANCE, and THERE IS NEVER ANY DEDUCTIBLE. That is why it is a higher monthly rate than phone company insurance, which almost always has a deductible.
3. YOU NEVER GET A NEW PHONE AS A REPLACEMENT. You will ALWAYS get a REFURBISHED PHONE. I can honestly tell you that with every refurbished phone I have seen, I have not been able to tell the difference compared to a new phone. If you can tell, you should say so.
4. I think some of you are mixing up elements of the Black Tie Protection Plan, and the Buy Back Plan. They are not the same thing.
5. You should pick a plan which is right for you and makes you happy! I personally do not want anyone to take Black Tie Protection when they neither want nor need it. We do not work on commission! I make the same amount of money whether I sell you an $800 iPhone or a $10 Go Phone, and whether you take Black Tie Protection or not. I also wish everyone (Best Buy employees included!) fully understood Black Tie Protection and how it works. I am sorry if anyone suffered because the elements were not clear.
6. This part is personal opinion. WE ARE ALL CARRYING $800 PHONES MADE OF GLASS AND CIRCUITRY. I feel insurance, and protection plans, are a form of legalized gambling. But with that $800 phone, and with as many of my friends as I have seen with cracked screens, I am hedging my bets.
7. I am not a Best Buy spokesman, and I really am a bottom-of-the-totem-pole, part-time, Best Buy Mobile employee (and it's not even my only job). NOTHING I say here is official or from the company, it's just my thoughts and opinions.
The End.
