• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Do you use a task killer?

What's your experience?


  • Total voters
    196
That doesn't make sense, 99% of the time a task killer can ONLY hurt. The only time it may be good is if you are using a BAD app in which case why are you using a bad app?

It's like traveling to Africa JUST so you have an excuse to go get a malaria shot...

Well even some applications that aren't necessarily bad, will tend to run on their own, in which case a task killer is quicker for me to check what's going on; for example, some new versions or betas that I want to try will have small bugs upon release which prevent sleeping, this doesn't mean it's a BAD app. And even if someone does download a BAD app, I guarantee you it isn't just for them to have an excuse to use a task killer.
Wow, 99%? That's a bit of a hyperbole, unless you're referring to those who do not know better than to let them auto-kill and wonder why their alarm doesn't go off. I've never had any problems with using a task killer, certainly not 99% of the time.
 
I only use a task killer under Froyo to kill a running app before I uninstall it. For instance, I was very impressed with PowerAMP beta, but it was running constantly and updating folders to find media, especially every time I disconnected BT from my car. I used the task killer to kill it, and uninstalled it.

I do not use task killers like I used to under eclair. I let the OS handle that stuff.
 
I use a task killer to manually kill selected apps, like some games or the camera. I don't use autokill, it only kills when I manually tell it to.
 
I had been a religious ATK user in the past and my phone would go about a day and a half on a charge. I started reading these battery threads and saw lots of people saying that you don't need a task killer running and that it actually hurts your battery life.

O.k. I thought, I'll try not using ATK since it was a pain in the butt to hit the button all the time.

After 2 days of not having a task killer working my battery wouldn't even last the day. There was times that my battery would drop 10% in less than an hour. I wasn't doing anything different except letting the apps run like they're supposed to in the background. Usage was the same, I just wasn't using the task killer.

I checked to see what was using the battery the most before and after too. Before "cell standby" was the major user low 30% or so I believe and "Android system" was really low like 12% while using ATK. While NOT using ATK Android System shot up to mid 30% usage and was the major battery drain with cell standby in 2nd place in the mid to upper 20% range.

I did this for a week and it was the same story, full battery (bump charged) at the beginning of the day, down to almost nothing by supper time.

I've since started using a task killer again to kill the apps that keep turning back on that I don't use (VZW navigator, Skype, etc) and I'm back up to a day and a half.

So I don't know what I'm doing wrong since I'm SURE it's all my fault, but I'm back in the task killer user camp.
 
I have the free version of System Panel on my phone. All autokill is turned off. I mainly just use it to monitor my phone. Watch the vital stats and stuff like that. I will occasionally manually kill a few apps. But those are apps that I use maybe once a day or apps that I use every now and then that decide to load but I don't want to delete. Like the camera, the calculator, the TV guide app, and a couple preloaded apps that you can kill and they don't come back, like Stocks. But mostly I just leave everything alone. If I see there is a lot of stuff in the list or theres a lot of stuff sitting in the memory I just reboot. Problem solved.
 
You obviously didn't read my post above.
there is no way you are going to convince me that you NEED that task killer on the phone. YOU are doing something wrong if you do. Some app isnt running correctly or settings are wrong, etc. Either way, something isnt right and you need to fix it, not mask it with the task killer
 
chances are if you use a task killer and encounter problems you are less likely to know they are problems because you are used to things being that way


that's how the first few weeks after owning my phone went (got the Incredible at launch). But then i educated myself and deleted that BS as fast as i could.
 
Today is my first full day without a task killer. I uninstalled it yesterday. As I've mentioned in other posts, I'm new to the Android OS having moved from BlackBerry after several years and Windows Mobile before that. So for me, loading a task killing app was logical. Hey, even the folks at Verizon and Best Buy said I need one, and they're never wrong.:rolleyes:

Here's the difference: prior to today, 40% battery left by lunch time. Today: 85% battery left at lunch time. Huge difference.
 
Task killer is a battery killer does more harm than good

This. ^

I got my Incredible about 2 weeks ago and virtually the same day I had installed the Task Killer. Battery life was very bad (below 15% by the time I was ready for bed, even with spot charging throughout the day), but I thought that was to be expected with frequent texting/e-mail checks. I uninstalled Task Killer Thursday and have since then had over 60% life (also with spot charging) by the time I was ready for bed.

From experience, (yes limited) I don't recommend.
 
I had been a religious ATK user in the past and my phone would go about a day and a half on a charge. I started reading these battery threads and saw lots of people saying that you don't need a task killer running and that it actually hurts your battery life.

O.k. I thought, I'll try not using ATK since it was a pain in the butt to hit the button all the time.

After 2 days of not having a task killer working my battery wouldn't even last the day. There was times that my battery would drop 10% in less than an hour. I wasn't doing anything different except letting the apps run like they're supposed to in the background. Usage was the same, I just wasn't using the task killer.

I checked to see what was using the battery the most before and after too. Before "cell standby" was the major user low 30% or so I believe and "Android system" was really low like 12% while using ATK. While NOT using ATK Android System shot up to mid 30% usage and was the major battery drain with cell standby in 2nd place in the mid to upper 20% range.

I did this for a week and it was the same story, full battery (bump charged) at the beginning of the day, down to almost nothing by supper time.

I've since started using a task killer again to kill the apps that keep turning back on that I don't use (VZW navigator, Skype, etc) and I'm back up to a day and a half.

So I don't know what I'm doing wrong since I'm SURE it's all my fault, but I'm back in the task killer user camp.

Sounds like you had an app keeping the phone awake. Typically when android sits at the top, it's simply because the phone is awake, but nothing is really running full tilt. Reboot, don't use the task killer ( If you do not have it set to auto, no need to bother uninstalling just yet...), and give the phone a bit to settle in. Next, check your up and awake times. Press the power button to put the phone to sleep and wait at least 10 mins, though the longer the better. Wake the phone back up, and quickly check the up and awake times. The awake time should have stayed almost the same ( when you press the power button to shut the screen off, the phone should be to sleep within a few seconds, though if you catch it during a sync or so it might take a couple mins. )

If the awake time did go up a fair bit however, you have a rogue app that is preventing the phone from sleeping. Sometimes it's just a setting in the app, a hiccup, or possibly the app is just plain bad. Unfortunately this usually takes some trial and error to figure out what app is misbehaving.

Also, never bother to kill Skype, VZ Navigator or City ID. They do not use power when in standby...and worse yet, they'll just come back ( and they do use power to start up. )

Finally: When your phone is asleep, you should see almost exactly a 1% drain per hour with mild syncs/etc. Even with a lot of syncing, when asleep you should not see more than a 2% drain per hour. This is excluding the first and last 10 percent of your battery, as battery gauges are not reliable past those ( IE Above 90 and below 10 percent. Typically above 90 goes faster than normal, and below 10 goes slower than normal, but it varies...hence being unreliable. )
 
Given that the Nexus 1 has the same screen and processor and has a rated talk time of 7 hours on 3G and the Desire has something like 61/2 hours, then why is the DI talk time only 5hr15min. The Nexus and Desire I think have 1400 mah batteries but this shouldn't make that much difference.
 
BTW I don't use a task killer. I have system panel and according to it, multiple apps such as Amazon, skype, stocks, city ID have not used any cpu time
 
Given that the Nexus 1 has the same screen and processor and has a rated talk time of 7 hours on 3G and the Desire has something like 61/2 hours, then why is the DI talk time only 5hr15min. The Nexus and Desire I think have 1400 mah batteries but this shouldn't make that much difference.

well by itself it should make about half an hour of difference. But more importantly, they both are on different networks. you can't compare their battery usage directly.

I don't see how this relates to taskillers thou...
 
I had been a religious ATK user in the past and my phone would go about a day and a half on a charge. I started reading these battery threads and saw lots of people saying that you don't need a task killer running and that it actually hurts your battery life.

O.k. I thought, I'll try not using ATK since it was a pain in the butt to hit the button all the time.

After 2 days of not having a task killer working my battery wouldn't even last the day. There was times that my battery would drop 10% in less than an hour. I wasn't doing anything different except letting the apps run like they're supposed to in the background. Usage was the same, I just wasn't using the task killer.

I checked to see what was using the battery the most before and after too. Before "cell standby" was the major user low 30% or so I believe and "Android system" was really low like 12% while using ATK. While NOT using ATK Android System shot up to mid 30% usage and was the major battery drain with cell standby in 2nd place in the mid to upper 20% range.

I did this for a week and it was the same story, full battery (bump charged) at the beginning of the day, down to almost nothing by supper time.

I've since started using a task killer again to kill the apps that keep turning back on that I don't use (VZW navigator, Skype, etc) and I'm back up to a day and a half.

So I don't know what I'm doing wrong since I'm SURE it's all my fault, but I'm back in the task killer user camp.

First thing to do is allow several days for your phone to relearn what was trashed on the phone's OS regarding memory management.
After running ATK for so long, the OS's built in task killer/memory management has been destroyed and will require time to rebuild itself !!
If it doesn't get back under control in a week, start searching for malicious apps you have loaded that are killing the battery.
 
First thing to do is allow several days for your phone to relearn what was trashed on the phone's OS regarding memory management.
After running ATK for so long, the OS's built in task killer/memory management has been destroyed and will require time to rebuild itself !!
If it doesn't get back under control in a week, start searching for malicious apps you have loaded that are killing the battery.

Um...no. Not really. The built in memory management should work fine after rebooting.

You almost certainly have a rouge app that's causing your troubles. Install system panel and try and figure out what that is.
 
Agreed on a rogue app or multiple rogue apps.
The Android system still learns how to manage itself as you install or uninstall apps and its not instantaneous.
 
I see no point in a task killer. Verizon initially installed one on my Inc but I took it off right after I got out of the store. Battery life is perfect and no slow downs.
 
i completely agree i had ATK installed on my when i was rooted and it MURDERED my extended battery life when i had to unroot my INC and start over i didn't put one back on there and my extended battery is now lasting me at least 50% longer then when i was using a task killer
~kid
 
Back
Top Bottom