• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

evo vs incredible

So I've been a huge fan of Verizon Wireless for several years now. Friends having even affectionately referred to me as Captain Verizon. The customer service, in my humble opinion, has been second to none in the telecommunication industry. My experience from my previous cellular provider (Sprint) was so bad, that I made a vow never to return to them. Now...I find myself writing on a some Android blog for the first time letting people know that I will be officially taking a break from the company I love to get my hands on the new Evo from Sprint.

I'll be honest, even if this phone was being offered on Verizon's network, I would probably still switch to Sprint at this point. It all boils down to cost. I've done the math and I just can't afford to stay on a cell plan that is ultimately costing me more per month for comparable services. Listen, I love Verizon, but they nickel and dime you for everything. You wan't visual voice mail, that'd be $2 - 3/month. You want texting...be prepared to pay $5 -20/month. You want data, that'd be another $25-45/month depending on the services that you chose. Add it all up, and the numbers are staggering.

In a nation that is going through one of the most difficult times financially for as long as I can remember, it's important to me to save where I can. I support my parents (bought them a house, pay for the cell phone, etc.) and each dollar I save, is another dollar I can use for something more meaningful (like food). If I were to have the same plan that I were to have on Sprint in June, my bill would easily run $180-$190/month on Verizon with three phones on my family plan. With Sprint, that cost is $150/month for a family plan with 1500 minutes. But here is the kicker, I get a 25% discount from my company on both plans. With Verizon, I get 25% off the primary line. With Sprint, it's 25% the entire bill. My new plan will be $112/month for three phones with basically everything unlimited. How can you argue with that?

On top of that, my folks will get to turn off their High Speed Internet from their local cable company that translates into a savings of $600/year. So not only am I leaving Verizon for a cool phone, I'm saving on a monthly service bill and eliminating another bill all at the same time. I'm sorry to leave Verizon, but at some point, you just have to say enough is enough.
 
Excellent post! Welcome to the forums.

(Also, I didn't know that discounts only applied to the head line on VZW accounts. This will make my switch from ATT to Sprint even easier [as compared to going from ATT to VZW, as I was going to do for the CDMA Nexus One, back in the day...].)
 
Gonna miss a trackpad, they say it's not needed because of the larger screen but I believe the opposite to be true. I'd like to be able to operate the phone one handed at times but will be hard with such a large screen..Would be doable with a trackpad.

It's harder to use the trackpad over the screen since its so close to the bottom.
 
I have been a Sprint customer for over 10 years and I've always been pleased with customer service, however I feel it has improved more recently. Side story - A few years back (before the Everything Plans) I had a month where my daughter had tethered her laptop to her phone and ran up a bill that was over $800. Working through Customer Service, I was able to get the extra charges reduced....to $0!!!

I love Sprint!

Ok, back to topic. I went to T-Mobile last week to check the size of the HD2 and then to Verizon to play with the Incredible. I think the Incredible is a great phone and if it were on Sprint and there was no Evo, I would likely go with it. The size of the HD2 was ideal for me, while the Incredible felt somewhat narrow.

We have a the family Everything plan (1500 cell minutes with text and data unlimited)with three phones and the monthly bill is right at $132 (thanks to a 20% company discount). We seldom use over 500 minutes combined since most of our calls are to other mobile phones.

Something else that I believe costs extra with Verizon and other carriers is the GPS navigation. I use it extensively, it works great and with our plan it's free!

So I am waiting, not-so-patiently, for the Evo!
 
Evo has no trackpad (which is very useful when browsing the internet to select tiny links) and the battery is only 200ma larger than the incredible which is nothing when you take into account the large screen. I dont understand peoples fascination on the screen size. Its the same 480x800 resolution....

Biggest problem with the Evo is its size. Evo does not fit into many pockets and will be very difficult for many to carry around which is why the Incredible will still be the #1 smartphone. Plus the Incredible has a far better still camera.

Evo 4g (IMO) is more of a micro tablet than a smartphone.
 
Plus the Incredible has a far better still camera.

Cause you have used the EVO's camera so many times and you know this for sure! Since all we are doing is GUESSING which you seem to be doing, I'm going to guess also and say I bet they are the SAME camera!
 
The 30" of course! Much easier to carry around from place to place. Same situation with the Evo and Inc. The Incredible can fit in my pocket, the Evo can not....

So I take it you've had many EVOs in your hand, right? Your post reminds me of that McDonalds vs BK commercials, you know the guy with the tiny hands?
 
He must really be wearing some nut huggers if the Evo can't fit in his pocket, considering its pretty much the same size as the iPhone.

I bet if sprint had the incredible and verizon was getting the evo, he would be singing a different tune. Like my mom use to tell me back in the day, denial is not just a river in egypt.
 
I'm with the Captain on this one. I am a huge fan of the VZW network, but I have to say that the costs are killing me. The "return charge" on the "30 worry free" guarantee is what has put me over the edge and into the EVO queue.
 
Actually I just did a size comparison with the Incredible and its pretty amazing how they compare.

The Evo is 0.17 x 0.3 x 0.03 inches bigger than the Incredible.
Or 4.5 x 7.5 x 1.1 millimeters bigger if you prefer the metric system.

HTC EVO 4G Size Compare (Phone Arena)


To try and definitively say the Evo won't fit in your pocket but the Incredible does is pretty funny. Very slightly taller and wider, and no real thickness difference.

But keep on posting random BS 5th Element.
 
Completely ignoring Verizon vs. Sprint and trying to stick with the hardware...

I think they're completely the same phone with some nuances that are big deals to some and not to others. For me, personally:

The 4G is cool, but it's not a HUGE selling feature to me for a few reasons:
- I don't think I would ever use that much speed on a phone app unless I was tethering
- My area doesn't support it yet and probably won't for at least a year
- I have a ridiculously fast FiOS install at my house

The HD output is HUGE for me because I watch a lot of DIVX / other media types on my Xbox 360. It can't decode them all, though, and more importantly, I don't have Xboxes on all of the HDTVs in my house, so having a portable media player that can play whatever videos the software can handle AND be able to output in HD is a pretty cool feature.

The capability to record video in HD at any time (since I carry my phone wherever I go) is also pretty cool, but ONLY if it records at a reasonable frame rate. I think the jury is still out on how this will perform, and if it performs poorly, if an "aftermarket" software solution can optimize the speed.

I like that the EVO is bigger. Primary reason being that I want to be able to type quickly and accurately and this is my first touchscreen phone. IF I was already used to this or knew that it wouldn't be an issue, I might actually want the Incredible's smaller screen size since it would fit in pockets more easily. No, I don't wear emo pants or whatever, but I don't think it's insane to want to minimize the size of the crap one hauls around every day.

I DO like the Incredible's trackball. I'm a fan of real hardware and having various methods of input. I can see where I'd get regular use out of it.

For me, I go with the EVO because of the video capabilities. 4G is cool and I'll love to test it out when I'm in an area that supports it, but it's just not a killer feature for me. I think the Incredible is a damned good phone as well, though. I don't understand the "LOL EVO IS SOOOOOOO MUCH BETTER" hype. They're practically the same phone. Shrug.
 
img1272909398930.jpg
 
You DO NOT roam on VZW data, just voice.

Sprint does indeed allow data roaming. I travel a lot and have not had many instances where I could not get a 3G signal while roaming. My BlackBerry (dont worry - soon to be EVO) will even tell me which network I am on while roaming and its not uncommon to see Verizon indicated.
 
Gonna miss a trackpad, they say it's not needed because of the larger screen but I believe the opposite to be true. I'd like to be able to operate the phone one handed at times but will be hard with such a large screen..Would be doable with a trackpad.

Trackpad on the Incredible is barely useful. Its slow, and not very responsive. It doesn't serve as any kind of notification light or indicator (unlike the trackball on the N1). The only use I have found for it is to occasionally move the text cursor one or two characters.

I was initially very skeptical of the cursor keys on the EVO pictures. Now I'm beginning to think they'll be far more efficient than any trackpad.

For one-hand use, I think you'll be better off using your thumb and swiping than using the trackpad.
 
iphone 4g vs nexus one vs evo 4g_04.jpg

Nexus One then Iphone then Evo 4g

Evo dwarfs the nexus and iphone....Im just saying, the phone is too big to fit in jeans pockets. Its my only beef with it. If it had a 4" screen then maybe I would grant the crown to it but due to the burrden the large screen causes the Incredible is still #1 . I dont want to carry around a miniture laptop bag to carry my phone.
 
Trackpad on the Incredible is barely useful. Its slow, and not very responsive. It doesn't serve as any kind of notification light or indicator (unlike the trackball on the N1). The only use I have found for it is to occasionally move the text cursor one or two characters.
The trackpad is invaluable when surfing the web and selecting tiny links. Without it you have to use your fingers, zoom in, and then try to touch the tiny link. PITA. Its SOOOOOOO easy with the trackpad, just scroll and click. No need to zoom and you can click the SMALLEST TINY links with ease.
 
Back
Top Bottom