OK, so I've tried both of these third party apps now for a few days and wanted to share my experience with you and get some feedback and possible work arounds etc.
BTW, It looks like even if android fixes the pin security issue we may still need to use third party apps to fill in gaps in the stock apps.
TD = Touchdown 4.0.0017, RS = Roadsync 1.0010(110)
TD supports global address book, RS does not. There is an app from Motorola to browse the GAB that works, but you need to have the stock sync configured. Like the stock corporate calendar it worked even without pin support.
TD shows meeting attendees, RS does not
RS compose new message a bit clunky, much better on TD
TD forces me to enter pin, RS does not
TD has link to location field for map
RS syncs to stock contacts app, TD does have option to copy (or is it integrate??) contacts to stock app
TD syncs tasks (though a little tough to navigate / sort), RS does not. Considering using Remember the Milk as an alternative. It syncs to the web app and has a few android client.
RS allows accept of invites sent via mail. - this feature alone is the one that may force me to use RS instead of TD, though most of the other features in TD are superior. Stock cal allows accept in cal app, not mail
Neither supports notes - looking to use evernote instead as there is an android beta available and I think it syncs with the web and desktop clients.
Neither cal widget looks to show the next, non all day item correctly
That's about it for now. I appreciate any feedback and suggestions for work arounds. I need to buy one of these and the TD trial has actually ended. I don't want to run both since I think it would drain the battery faster doing extra polling. I also want to cut down the noise in the notifications and app collection.
John