Third try was successful. First two times I did it, since it was 2 different PCs, I had to install Kies. I hooked the phone up before installing it, which seems to have made a difference.
On the third try, Kies was already installed and I opened it before hooking up the phone cord. Well, the phone went into some USB mode which it didn't do before. Worked flawlessly. So if anyone is reading this post and has the same issue as me, make sure kies is installed and running before you connect your phone. (It may have just been a fluke, too)
Chris