• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Gmail App vs HTC Mail App

G

gatekeeper

Lurker
I'm having trouble deciding because both of them have their pros and cons, but the main pros/cons being:

GMail Pros:
Receives mail instantly
Labels

Gmail Cons:
Does not get "green bubble" numerical notifications (like with text messages)

HTC Pros:
Green Bubble Notifications
Easier access to multiple accounts

HTC Cons:
Takes forever to receive mail
(ex. Received an email at 3:10. Gmail got it at 3:10 but HTC never got it till 3:27)

Basically, is there a way to turn on the green bubble notifications for Gmail? While I like HTC's Mail client, I'd rather get my mail quicker over style.
 
I had a few more cons with the HTC mail so I went with the gmail one and got gmail unread count to give you that bubble you are looking for.
 
That's odd, I get push gmail, and it shows me the unread count, and yeah, easy access to labels. Do you have background sync, and mobile data on?
 
Ya, plenty of gmail unread widgets out there.

Which leaves only one CON, which is still my biggest pet peeve, opening and switching between two gmail accounts. I can make two shortcuts, one for each account, but each one opens up the app, and whichever account was opened last, it opens.


Also, when I email something from the OS, and I choose Gmail to send it, it uses whichever account I used last. So I'll have to quit, open Gmail, switch to the right account. Then go back and send the thing I was trying to send. I wish Android handled these email settings better.
 
If you set up Gmail as an Exchange in HTC Mail, can't you get push? That's how it works with my iTouch. Don't have my Incredible yet can't test for myself.

Edit: nvm I forgot, HTC Mail doesn't support IMAP IDLE.
 
Thanks for the unread widget suggestion! Just got the phone 2 days ago so still working out the kinks and getting used to it. I forgot Google allows you to do whatever and doesn't have something stuck up their butt like Apple.
 
sail4fun201 said:
If you set up Gmail as an Exchange in HTC Sync, can't you get push? That's how it works with my iTouch. Don't have my Incredible yet can't test for myself.
Click to expand...

It did for me. I used to use HTC Mail for my gmail, as I liked the interface better, and I got emails almost instantaneously. I switched back to Gmail App because I couldn't get rid of an issue where I'd get sound notifications for the same email over and over. Tried everything to no avail. I also like the Gmail Delete button placement better (as trivial as this may sound, I use it on the majority of my emails).
 
I use my school e-mail on exchange with the HTC app, and then Gmail with the "Gmail Unread Count 1.2.2" (which works really well and gives you some customizable options, like for the icon).
 
HTC mail app on exchange is superior to Gmail app in virtually every single way.
Click to expand...
Except that (for me anyways) HTC takes forever to get mail.

Also, I downloaded the Gmail Unread Count App and it works great.... except it only works on one gmail account at a time. I'd rather it give me one combined amount of unread emails.
 
I like the Gmail app. The speed is great but I use 4 gmail accounts. It is a complete PITA to switch back and forth between accounts. If any app can fix this, it will get my vote.
 
ajiamarie said:
I like the Gmail app. The speed is great but I use 4 gmail accounts. It is a complete PITA to switch back and forth between accounts. If any app can fix this, it will get my vote.
Click to expand...

See my post above yours! It has a combined in box, and each email is color coded to the account it comes from! Works awesome, and you don't have to keep switching back and forth between accounts!
 
dspanos said:
I hated both of them so I installed the Droid's combined in box email and never looked back. It's much better than either of the apps that come on the Incredible. If you are interested just google Droid email.apk, copy it to your SD card, and install!

Edited: Here is the link... Vanilla Email.apk - xda-developers
Click to expand...

Which one you use the vanilla one of the other.
I think the second needs to be pushed via ADB?

Thanks
 
n0m0n said:
Which one you use the vanilla one of the other.
I think the second needs to be pushed via ADB?

Thanks
Click to expand...

I use the vanilla one. I used to have the Droid, and it works the same without having to do all that extra crap to get it installed.
 
I don't like that you can't delete or edit the original email when replying in the Gmail app. I think it's ******ed that you're forced to include it as quoted text. At least with the HTC app the original email can be deleted.
 
I don't like how the gmail web client quotes text when you reply. The one line "At this date, this person wrote:" is really sloppy, especially compared to Outlook 2010's implementation of a pretty classy quote preface.

Is this the way it is in the Gmail app, too? What about the HTC Mail app?
 
Wow, I take it back. Just started using HTC Mail via Exchange Activesync again. Got email in Outlook about 5 minutes ago, hasn't showed up on the phone yet...that's pretty bad.

I have the sync settings on "as mail arrives". Not sure what the hold-up is. I love everything about the HTC mail app, but first and foremost I need a mail app that reliably syncs with Gmail.

UPDATE: OK, got the emails after 10 minutes. Strangely, it appears the sync got triggered when a brand new piece of mail came in that is not a part of any conversation. Could it be that Exchange only syncs on non-threaded messages?
 
The HTC app wasn't giving me HTML Email, so I use the GMAIL app.

I tried the email app DSPANOS linked to.. but it doesn't have a widget, also everytime you go into it, you have to select the account or Combined, you can't set it to default open to the combine, so it doesn't really seem to save me anything. Also it's timed polling, not push like the native gmail. lastly, I always look at the email via the notification bar. When you access your gmail via your notification bar it takes you to the account box, not the unified box. Nitpicky, yes, but it kinda takes away from the whole unified box thing. nope, one more thing, when you view the email via the notification bar and it opens the mail, it does NOT count it as read. When you back out it still shows as new. So totally pointless now.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom