• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

Help iPhone 4S to S3

Mac's are not compatible with NTFS drives either, does that mean that NTFS is at fault? Or mac?

OSX does not support MTP out of the box.
Connecting to a Macintosh computer via USB - Android OS Help

And here's why they did it.

Ice Cream Sandwich explained: MTP - what is it, why use it, and how to set it up | Android Central
------- from above site ------------
We didn't do this because we wanted to use ext3 (although that is a side benefit.) We did it because we wanted to be able to merge the "public shared storage" (i.e. for music and photos) with the internal private app storage.

We got tired of seeing OEMs include many GB of internal storage for music, while users were still running out of space for apps and data. This approach lets us merge everything on one volume, which is way better.
-----------------------------------
Lets go ahead and take this one level deeper, since you argue that the mac came out before the sg3, so it should be compatible, mtp came out before the current version of osx, why isn't it compatible, it is a standard afterall.

So we should stay technically behind because apple refuses to let their computers connect to digital cameras, mp3 players other than their own brand.

Yes the razr supports it, but then the file system is exfat, and I've had both the sg3 and razr, and the sg3 runs circles performance wise to the razr, and I'd rather run with ext3 vs exfat in my phone.
This is exactly what I was looking for. Great post. Thanks!
 
Well, they think I'm nuts at the Best Buy but I returned the RAZR as I didn't like the UI and that the charge plug is at the top and decided to get another S3. All the constructive comments in this thread and elsewhere on this site and others really helped me get a grasp of how Android is supposed to work. I may purge my body of iDNA yet.
 
The Maxx is a good phone, has a killer battery but is now a generation behind. I still order them for field people and people that don't want all the choices that they sg3 has, the Maxx also has really good radios better than the galaxy 3. I'd say that the sg3 is a computer first phone second and it is opposite for the Maxx..

I devices came out during a time that people still synced with their computers, when bandwidth was hard to come by and slow. That time has passed. My lte is faster than my cable modem and WiFi is becoming ubiquitous, so Google has taken it to the next level and untied the phone from the computer, and built it into the os. I have used icloud before on I devices that I support and it feels totally bolted on, no undelete for contacts on icloud and just not where Google is with Gmail. Yes it doesn't do a full recovery but that isn't always a bad thing, I guess it's all perspective.

Did you see the otg cables? Be able to plug other devices into your phone and tablet, like flash drives, mice and keyboards? Amazon has them for 89 cents or so.

Also microusb, some hate it lots like it but it is sooooo nice to have charger for everything and not have it costs a fortune.

Lots of choices, and that isn't bad. Also there is video out check for the mhl connector I think, it is a connector that is on the sg3 that apple could have used if they weren't out to milk people, it does everything that people say they want out a plug without a drm chip in it.

Does android take a little work sure, but that work means that it is customized for you, how your mind works, how you want to see things.

Have you seen tektags?
 
Here's a fun and interesting new development: Tonight I plugged it into my Mac and it mounted and popped open a file browser!!! I copied a file to it and it worked like a charm. WTH?

The one that was giving me fits was on Verizon and my new one is on at&t.
 
The S3 is the only external device I've had problems with on my Macs in over 7 years.

Then you missed when they cut off support for Olympus cameras and the rest of Android phones that supported the Digital Image Media standards.

Support for the SGS3 is far from perfect, but it's not all on Samsung's side.

Just saying. ;)
 
mtp came out before the current version of osx, why isn't it compatible, it is a standard afterall.

All I know is that OS X came before the SGS3. The fact that it is completely incompatible with OS X, is quite embarrassing, especially when they're desperately trying to snatch up iUpgraders. It's no excuse blaming OS X. There should be some official software available, from Samsung/Google, to sort this.

Tell me - if you go out and buy a generic tech product, bring it home, plug it into your PC and find out it's incompatible. Who is to blame? Microsoft? No. Windows has been around for a lot longer than that product in your hands. Products are made to work with OS', not the other way round. I've never seen a box with "probably compatible with Windows 9, 2015" on the side.

I am now using Windows on my Mac to sync my i9300. It's a minor irritation for me, but someone with less time/know-how would find this unacceptable. It means I can't use Apple's sync services to keep copies of backups on my iMac and MacBook Pro.
 
All I know is that OS X came before the SGS3. The fact that it is completely incompatible with OS X, is quite embarrassing, especially when they're desperately trying to snatch up iUpgraders. It's no excuse blaming OS X. There should be some official software available, from Samsung/Google, to sort this.

Tell me - if you go out and buy a generic tech product, bring it home, plug it into your PC and find out it's incompatible. Who is to blame? Microsoft? No. Windows has been around for a lot longer than that product in your hands. Products are made to work with OS', not the other way round. I've never seen a box with "probably compatible with Windows 9, 2015" on the side.

I am now using Windows on my Mac to sync my i9300. It's a minor irritation for me, but someone with less time/know-how would find this unacceptable. It means I can't use Apple's sync services to keep copies of backups on my iMac and MacBook Pro.

Do you really think it is abnormal that you cannot sync Android to iPhone? To me it is nto strange. It is like saying that the engine from your Mazda somehow dose not fit a Porsche.

Here is your solution:

http://www.samsung.com/uk/support/usefulsoftware/KIES/JSP
 
All I know is that OS X came before the SGS3. The fact that it is completely incompatible with OS X, is quite embarrassing, especially when they're desperately trying to snatch up iUpgraders. It's no excuse blaming OS X. There should be some official software available, from Samsung/Google, to sort this.

Tell me - if you go out and buy a generic tech product, bring it home, plug it into your PC and find out it's incompatible. Who is to blame? Microsoft? No. Windows has been around for a lot longer than that product in your hands. Products are made to work with OS', not the other way round. I've never seen a box with "probably compatible with Windows 9, 2015" on the side.

I am now using Windows on my Mac to sync my i9300. It's a minor irritation for me, but someone with less time/know-how would find this unacceptable. It means I can't use Apple's sync services to keep copies of backups on my iMac and MacBook Pro.

Well, manufacturers have to support existing standards; however, they need to choose which ones to support. The reason that some decide not to support OSX is because only a small percentage of users owns Macs. This percentage is even lower overseas. At the end, Samsung needs to make choices that have an impact on development costs and support and it chose not to support the OSX. Knowing the rather "adversarial" relationship between Apple and Samsung, I cannot say that I blame them.
 
All I know is that OS X came before the SGS3. The fact that it is completely incompatible with OS X, is quite embarrassing, especially when they're desperately trying to snatch up iUpgraders. It's no excuse blaming OS X. There should be some official software available, from Samsung/Google, to sort this.

Tell me - if you go out and buy a generic tech product, bring it home, plug it into your PC and find out it's incompatible. Who is to blame? Microsoft? No. Windows has been around for a lot longer than that product in your hands. Products are made to work with OS', not the other way round. I've never seen a box with "probably compatible with Windows 9, 2015" on the side.

I am now using Windows on my Mac to sync my i9300. It's a minor irritation for me, but someone with less time/know-how would find this unacceptable. It means I can't use Apple's sync services to keep copies of backups on my iMac and MacBook Pro.
Well, I hate to say this, but I doubt Google or Samsung give much concern over what amounts to relatively few users of OSX and just a percentage of that are having issues. Additionally, Mountain Lion was just released. Do you know how many 3rd party Apple apps didn't function when I upgraded from Snow Leopard to Lion? It was so bad, I reverted back to SL! So should I blame Apple, because software companies are slow to adapt? Do you blame developers of apps or Apple for causing 90% of ios apps to letterboxing to 3.5" on the iphone 5.

Now, if you want to sync things from any platform to another, regardless of pc, mac, tablet, ipad, android phone, iphone or smart tv, and regardless of what kind of file it is, then download Dropbox and Dropsync. Problem solved.

By the way, I have a 27" iMac running Lion and have no issues plugging my S3 into it and using Keis. Good luck to you.
 
Kies works flawless on OSX 10.8.2 and if you want the "Finder" look of your internal drive or SDcard , you do it from the Summary tab just clock the explore button beside the desired drive
 
MTP is a Windows standard.

Google came out with Android File Transfer to not lose the Mac owners. That small percentage is a big number so it matters.

Samsung has screwed up MTP several times. (Links of coding errors by them are available on the web.)

Apple has purposely screwed up Android and Google interfaces, more than once.

Android is Linux. Mac is unix. Anything less than plug in simplicity is the fault of all parties involved except the users.
 
Do you really think it is abnormal that you cannot sync Android to iPhone? To me it is nto strange. It is like saying that the engine from your Mazda somehow dose not fit a Porsche.

Sync Android to iPhone? You have misunderstood the discussion.

@EarlyMon, agreed.

@Covart/Heisenberg - I'm also on a 27" iMac, OS X 10.8.2. Installing Kies is ok, plugging Samsung in does quite literally nothing. The S3 goes into MTP, my iMac sits there, silent. I'm going for a reinstall...

Edit: Reinstall worked on iMac!!
 
Back
Top Bottom