• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

New Epic 4g review (Engadget w/ video)

pablo.station said:
Engadget reviews get to be a bit annoying at times. If its not an iphone, its just "ok"
Click to expand...

Yeah, I didn't think anyone else noticed their tendency to downplay any device if it's not an iProduct.

Reading the whole review, I am confused. They talk poorly of the Epic throughout, then wrap it all up saying they strongly recommend it, saying it is "Killer". It makes my head hurt.

Sad to see that the aGPS bug is alive on the Epic. +1 to dietcoke, lol. (for now at least :cool:)

And I don't know what was up with those videos, I have seen some really good examples elsewhere, even samples from the captivate/vibrant look excellent by comparison. You can check out user submitted samples on the Galaxy S facebook page. Maybe whatever they use to host them is causing problems...
 
  • Like
Reactions: it.
31st can't come soon enough. At my work, friends 4g card can get 10mbps and at home I have seen 9-12 mbps on clear. I'm one of the lucky ones who have a 4g network that rivals sprints 3g network around my home area. Plus a hacked PRL so I have full 3g coverage from VZW if needed. Can't get any better than that.....
 
Nucleartx said:
31st can't come soon enough. At my work, friends 4g card can get 10mbps and at home I have seen 9-12 mbps on clear. I'm one of the lucky ones who have a 4g network that rivals sprints 3g network around my home area. Plus a hacked PRL so I have full 3g coverage from VZW if needed. Can't get any better than that.....
Click to expand...

Sounds about like Corpus Christi... I'm gonna guess you live in Austin though.
 
Adrift said:
Yeah, I didn't think anyone else noticed their tendency to downplay any device if it's not an iProduct.

Reading the whole review, I am confused. They talk poorly of the Epic throughout, then wrap it all up saying they strongly recommend it, saying it is "Killer". It makes my head hurt.

Sad to see that the aGPS bug is alive on the Epic. +1 to dietcoke, lol. (for now at least :cool:)

And I don't know what was up with those videos, I have seen some really good examples elsewhere, even samples from the captivate/vibrant look excelent by comparison. You can check out user submitted samples on the Galaxy S facebook page. Maybe whatever they use to host them is causing problems...
Click to expand...
lol. I completely agree
 
Didnt see any of the videos in te engadget review yet but overall it seemed to be a good review. I dont agree with everything said but thats life. Btw, I am typing this post on my "dismall" Samsung Moment keyboard. (I dont think its dismall btw, engadget did)
 
The gizmodo review is overwhelmingly positive and Engadget's review has a negative vibe to it. They're pretty much complete opposites....
 
pablo.station said:
scroll up a bit more to the second post bud. already posted the link for that and the slashgear review...
Click to expand...

whoops, sorry. I got so caught up and excited in this whole flood of Epic videos and reviews that I didn't notice. I deleted the link
 
Anybody read in the slashgear review...

Best of all, the GPS issues which many have reported affecting Galaxy S family devices aren’t apparent on the Epic 4G, with our review unit proving capable of quickly establishing a fix and tracking it accordingly.
Click to expand...
 
Pitbull329 said:
Anybody read in the slashgear review...
Click to expand...

Ha, was just about to post about that...

Plus, they say that the Epic is free of the "Galaxy S Lag" that other Galaxy S devices suffer from. This points to the Epic (possibly) using NAND style over internal SD.

:D:D - This makes me happy.
 
it. said:
I know. Everyone is giving it really amazing reviews. The 31st can't come soon enough :D
Click to expand...

Yea, I know! Im still using an oldish Samsung flip phone(have about 2yrs with it) but hey! Its been to hell and back and still works like a charm.:cool:

This will end up being my first smartphone. Have been interested on android for a while, never shown interest for any iphone one bit.
 
With all these reviews coming out ALMOST TWO WEEKS before the release of the phone, anyone think they might release the phone a bit sooner because of the good reviews the Epic has received so far?

epic-4g-review-04.jpg
 
pablo.station said:
With all these reviews coming out ALMOST TWO WEEKS before the release of the phone, anyone think they might release the phone a bit sooner because of the good reviews the Epic has received so far?
Click to expand...

Ha, I am guessing that that is the wish of most members here. I know that is my wish. :D

Would be great if Sprint played a joke and said "August 31st was just speculation, the 20th is the true date" We wake up the morning of the 20th to find stocks of Epics on the store shelves. Yeah, a man can dream...
 
From a hardware perspective, this phone seems pretty much flawless. And when Cyanogen's CM6 with Froyo comes out, you'll be pretty hard pressed to find a major gripe with this phone.
 
My main concern after readin those reviews is what engadget said :
To our surprise, also missing is the neat "puzzle lock" mode available on the Captivate and Vibrant, which allows you to immediately view messages, missed calls, and the like by dragging and dropping a puzzle piece into its matching hole on the screen.
Click to expand...
I loved that feature on Touchwiz. IDK how long I will use Touchwiz, but to me that was a really cool feature, and honestly if it doesn't have that I am much more inclined to install launcher pro or ADW.
 
If lock screen can't show missed call/messages, that would be a bummer. Engadget review also complains that you can't mute the ringer from the lock screen. When I went to checkout Vibrant in tmobile store last month, the rep showed me that you can just press and hold power button even on lock screen and it brings up the menu to toggle ringer. I wonder if it is gone from Epic. It will be bad if it so. Also, one other thing that I am really afraid of right now was the music playback controls widget that appeared on the top of the lock screen in form of half CD. If they moved the clock on top of the screen, I fear they would must have left the widget out. With these three things out, lock screen will be just useless and would just hope some developer will port the captivate lock screen to Epic.
 
The engadget review had an update that said gps was fixed. What!!?? Cool, I hope they are right. They don't like keyboard as much and EVO has slight edge.

Gizmodo, iPhone fansite, actually loves the Epic. Bested the EVO (hinted better than iPhone but too scared to print) and best keyboard ever.

Gizmodo reviewer must have smaller thumbs.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom