After listening to a lot on the turntable I find some things I like better on vinyl, others on CD.
Probably because my primary instrument is saxophone, I find most sax players better on vinyl. The tone on digital recordings adds an unrealistic edge. The general public might not notice that, but sax players work on their tone all their lives.
Cool school jazz seems to sound better on vinyl.
Symphonies sound better on CD, but I have some out of print classics that aren't available on CD, it's good to hear them again. I'll probably take the time to digitize them some day, but it's the tourist season down here and the gigging is plenty.
CDs put an edge or sheen on everything. It's part of the process at the CD bitrate. One of the inventors of the CD in an article I read in a trade mag said CDs have severe quantization errors and (unrelated) add some high harmonics not present in the original tone of the voice or instrument.
On the other hand, Vinyl has surface noise and as the record wears, a degradation of the high frequencies.
So it's a matter of which distortion do you prefer for the particular thing you are listening to.
Right now I've got the windows open and I'm listening to the tropical breezes and the birds singing, but I'm probably going to put a recording on soon.
Notes