I got an initial SGS3 sent from Verizon and within the first few hours I noticed a scratch on the screen, even though I hadn't dropped or damaged it. I'm not sure if it came that way (and I just didn't notice it initially) or it scratched against a key in my pocket, but I basically called Verizon and asked them to send me a new one, which they did. While I was waiting for that one to arrive, I was sitting outdoors in a restaurant and the phone slipped out of my shorts pocket and fell on the concrete floor face down...and then my initial small scratch was dwarfed by a long crack running horizontally across the screen. I was pretty horified and became worried that I just bought-into a very fragile phone.
Prior to this phone, I had the Fascinate for almost two years, went completely naked, and despite the occasional drop, the screen never cracked once. My fear before purchasing the SGS3 was that it would be too big, but I was sold by it's sleek form factor and its light weight. I imagined that if anything the SGS3 would be more durable since it was a newer generation by the same company. So I decided to purchase it never contemplating that I'd need a case or screen protector.
I got the new shipment from Verizon Monday and I'm still not sure if the first phone I got was defective or if the SGS3 is just incredibly fragile. I started with a full-body condom (screen protector and case) but I quickly got irritated with the lack of screen responsiveness. I also hated the hazy/humid look that a protector creates and began to wonder why I'd drop over $200 on a phone with a sick screen if I'm just going to stick a rubber on it. Finally, the dark layer of the screen protector forced me to compensate by turning up the brightness, which only further drained my battery. SO, I am now going with a rubber case and no screen protector.
I think I will keep it on at work (when I can throw it in my suit jacket-pocket) or when I've got deep pockets like cargo shorts, but will strip the case when I'm going out for the night and want to be lower profile (unfortunately, this is usually when my recreational affinity for alcoholic beverages increases my likelihood of the incidental drop). But knowing myself, I guess it's only a matter of time before I start going totally commando 24-7.