Oh man. Seriously duh. I have been googling this for the past hour and a half trying to figure out what was wrong. I am rooting my husband's phone and everything was perfectly perfect ...except I couldn't do anything with CWM. Talk about frustrating. Every other boot or recovery menu requires the use of the power button to select options. So naturally, I'm pressing the power button and it's not working. Thanks for this. I'm not sure I would have ever found the solution on my own, especially since there is nothing on the screen to indicate that their menu functions differently from the default menus lol. Wow.