I'll have to disagree with you on this. A small percentage of people are having reception issues with the S3. A lot of people are looking at signal bars and dBm readings and assuming poor reception even if they haven't had any dropped calls or data issues. I don't know if there was a bad batch of phones or what, but it seems very odd that there are phones that are beating the Motos in side by side signal performance and phones that are actually worse than the Gnex on a bad day.
My S3's reception is as good if not better than my DX both in real world use and watching the signal strength it reports.
I do feel your pain though. I had a Samsung Saga before the DX and it was terrible at holding a signal. Dropped calls while sitting still if you turned your head the wrong way, and I'm not joking...
All this being said, IF the Fighter/Razr HD would have been a choice when VZN forced our hands to keep unlimited data, I probably would have chose to go with it based on my previous experience with the DX and Saga regardless of whether the S3 had great reception or not. So far, I am not regretting going with the S3.
I tried not to fall into the signal vs. bars thing, but when it came down to it, I've made called with my DX and my wifes Maxx in my bedroom for 1 year and have never dropped a call. I've had several dropped calls in the 4 days I had it.
On my hour long drive to work in weaker areas of only 3G, I'd get pauses in streaming radio playback with the S3. For the past year, streaming has been almost perfect with the DX.
What killed it for me was sitting in bed and the S3 says no connection and I verified I cannot connect to the internet, app store, etc while my wifes Maxx had 3 bars of 4G and was chuckelling at my "new" phone.
Even if it wasn't an issue, I do a lot of GPS use with the DX in my window. The S3 was very difficult to see the smaller road on google maps that were small gray lines. I just wasn't bright enough. That and due to my 1-hour drive each way to work, I stream to my car stereo all the time. Having to unplug the headphone to take a call was a pain also.
Just a few little things that added up to make it not worth it. Really, 9M pre-orders cant all have issues. I just did and will be hoping the Fighter/DC HD is better.
The 4G on the S3 was smoking fast though as well as with WiFi connected.
I've had a lot of issues with restarts with my DX, but have a feeling it needs to have a factory reset to clean it up again. So many things don't uninstall properly when dealing with device location, security, ect. Right now I'm having issues removing Avast.