M
Member203005
Guest
Being a user of both, I can give a little more insight than those who have not used both. But this is just my experience and your mileage may vary.
I'm also a new user of a Droid X. This is my first Android device. Overall I like it. It is a good phone. It's so much better than my previous Blackberry. Its not as good as my wife's iPhone.
For me, the iPhone is much easier to use. I like a phone, or other consumer device that I can just fire up and use. It already looks good, its responsive and it's secure. I don't want to worry about downloading malware when looking for apps. I don't want to have to worry about my wallpaper app stealing my private data and shipping it to a nefarious server in Shenzen. I like the fact, as a consumer, that the apps I've downloaded have been tested for stability, usability, and security before they are sold in a store. I like the fact, that I don't have to worry about porn when looking for apps. If I was a developer, I might not like those things as much. But as a consumer, they are great!
I don't want to have to customize my phone bc the stock OS looks like total crap. Or have to rely on a carrier to provide a good looking UI. Bc then I have to wait on that carrier to get its act together before I can get the latest update. And I have to learn about an app like BetterCut, or learn how to follow a 6 step process for changing icons, setting up LauncherPro, etc.
You may not like having to tether your phone to a computer to get it working. You may like to manage your own file system on your phone. I do not. I don't want to have to learn the file system. I don't want to have to set my phone as a USB connection type before my computer will let me connect to it. I don't want to have to learn what an apk file is and what folder to move it to. I don't want to have to manage all of my photos, music, videos on the actual phone. I want to do that with an integrated program on my computer. I want to have it set up so when I plug it in, the syncing just happens. Backups are seamless, music is appropriately copied over, and my already organized photo library is in place.
Looks matter to me. And on some level it matters to all of us. None of us like to look at shitty graphics and horrible color/font choices in our applications. But that's what I'm dealing with while using my Droid X. If anyone has ever used an iPhone you know the stark differences between the design quality of Cocoa Touch apps and Android apps. It's huge. iPhone developers care a great deal about how they apps look and feel. I don't get that same feeling with using an Android App.
For example, I'm a huge RSS reader. I spend a lot of time reading various blogs on design, film, tech, etc. I have yet to find a good RSS app on the Marketplace for this. There is no peer to Reeder on the iPhone in the Marketplace. Not only is its UI exquisite, but it's about 100 times more functional than the best alternative I can find on Android (either NewsRob or A Good Reader).
iPhone apps all work the same way. You download them, they install onto your home screen. You touch them to open them up and interact with them by using the screen. And only the screen. this consistency means that the learning curve is extremely low. All of the commands are on the screen. You only have to touch the screen to navigate the app. This is very easy to use and very intuitive. If I don't want it anymore, I simply long press and delete it.
Android apps work differently. You may download an app, and it'll go into your app drawer. Unless its something like LauncherPro, in which case I'm not sure where it goes. If I wasn't a techie, I'd be confused. Beautiful Widgets. And they are beautiful, if I can find them. But it doesn't behave like an app bc its a widget and you create/access widgets in a different manner than apps. So now I have 3 different types of applications with 3 different ways to access them and use them. Is it mind-boggling? Of course not. But its not simple either.
How do I delete an app? Simple, I just click the menu hardware button, select Manage Applications find the app I'm looking for and click Uninstall. Unless it's a totally stupid app that I don't want taking up space on my phone. Those I can't delete. Motorola/Verizon has decided that I need those to help make them money. This is an open phone, except when it comes to bloatware. Then it's not.
How do I navigate inside an app? Well it depends. Most of the time I use the hardware buttons. Basically, you use the back button to move between areas of the application. Its like a browser. Which can be efficient if used properly. But most times its like a poorly deisgned web app where instead of solving a complicated UI problem, the designer just tells you to hit the back button. I'm listening to my music, I like the artist, but I can't jump to taht artist. No, I have to hit back 3 times before I'm presented with an option to scroll through my artists since I'm in a playlist. Or, if I'm in the camera app, I actually touch on the screen to get some menu options. So I do that, and then I can get to some pictures I've taken before. How do I get back to the camera? That's now the back button 3 times again. That's pretty arbitrary. And that is in the same app!
I have an 8 MP camera! Except it defaults to 6 MP. I didn't even know that until I was writing this post and went into the settings and saw that it was set for 6 MP. I thought the face detection was broken. The little reticule didn't pick up the faces no matter how often I touched them. Oh but that's a setting too. I need to go into it Settings and turn that on.
You see how this could be confusing to a non-techie, or even a techie. The iPhone may not have as many features (I wish it had different effects like my Droid X) but the features it does have just work. I don't need to tinker with them to turn them on. It has a 5 MP camera and it shoots in 5 MP. It doesn't start with 3 and wait for me to turn it up to 5.
This is just a few examples. I'm finding more every day.
Now, don't get me wrong. I really like my Droid X. I think like an arranged marriage (afterall it was issued to me by work) I'll grow to love it. But is it as easy to use as an iPhone? No it is not.
I'm also a new user of a Droid X. This is my first Android device. Overall I like it. It is a good phone. It's so much better than my previous Blackberry. Its not as good as my wife's iPhone.
For me, the iPhone is much easier to use. I like a phone, or other consumer device that I can just fire up and use. It already looks good, its responsive and it's secure. I don't want to worry about downloading malware when looking for apps. I don't want to have to worry about my wallpaper app stealing my private data and shipping it to a nefarious server in Shenzen. I like the fact, as a consumer, that the apps I've downloaded have been tested for stability, usability, and security before they are sold in a store. I like the fact, that I don't have to worry about porn when looking for apps. If I was a developer, I might not like those things as much. But as a consumer, they are great!
I don't want to have to customize my phone bc the stock OS looks like total crap. Or have to rely on a carrier to provide a good looking UI. Bc then I have to wait on that carrier to get its act together before I can get the latest update. And I have to learn about an app like BetterCut, or learn how to follow a 6 step process for changing icons, setting up LauncherPro, etc.
You may not like having to tether your phone to a computer to get it working. You may like to manage your own file system on your phone. I do not. I don't want to have to learn the file system. I don't want to have to set my phone as a USB connection type before my computer will let me connect to it. I don't want to have to learn what an apk file is and what folder to move it to. I don't want to have to manage all of my photos, music, videos on the actual phone. I want to do that with an integrated program on my computer. I want to have it set up so when I plug it in, the syncing just happens. Backups are seamless, music is appropriately copied over, and my already organized photo library is in place.
Looks matter to me. And on some level it matters to all of us. None of us like to look at shitty graphics and horrible color/font choices in our applications. But that's what I'm dealing with while using my Droid X. If anyone has ever used an iPhone you know the stark differences between the design quality of Cocoa Touch apps and Android apps. It's huge. iPhone developers care a great deal about how they apps look and feel. I don't get that same feeling with using an Android App.
For example, I'm a huge RSS reader. I spend a lot of time reading various blogs on design, film, tech, etc. I have yet to find a good RSS app on the Marketplace for this. There is no peer to Reeder on the iPhone in the Marketplace. Not only is its UI exquisite, but it's about 100 times more functional than the best alternative I can find on Android (either NewsRob or A Good Reader).
iPhone apps all work the same way. You download them, they install onto your home screen. You touch them to open them up and interact with them by using the screen. And only the screen. this consistency means that the learning curve is extremely low. All of the commands are on the screen. You only have to touch the screen to navigate the app. This is very easy to use and very intuitive. If I don't want it anymore, I simply long press and delete it.
Android apps work differently. You may download an app, and it'll go into your app drawer. Unless its something like LauncherPro, in which case I'm not sure where it goes. If I wasn't a techie, I'd be confused. Beautiful Widgets. And they are beautiful, if I can find them. But it doesn't behave like an app bc its a widget and you create/access widgets in a different manner than apps. So now I have 3 different types of applications with 3 different ways to access them and use them. Is it mind-boggling? Of course not. But its not simple either.
How do I delete an app? Simple, I just click the menu hardware button, select Manage Applications find the app I'm looking for and click Uninstall. Unless it's a totally stupid app that I don't want taking up space on my phone. Those I can't delete. Motorola/Verizon has decided that I need those to help make them money. This is an open phone, except when it comes to bloatware. Then it's not.
How do I navigate inside an app? Well it depends. Most of the time I use the hardware buttons. Basically, you use the back button to move between areas of the application. Its like a browser. Which can be efficient if used properly. But most times its like a poorly deisgned web app where instead of solving a complicated UI problem, the designer just tells you to hit the back button. I'm listening to my music, I like the artist, but I can't jump to taht artist. No, I have to hit back 3 times before I'm presented with an option to scroll through my artists since I'm in a playlist. Or, if I'm in the camera app, I actually touch on the screen to get some menu options. So I do that, and then I can get to some pictures I've taken before. How do I get back to the camera? That's now the back button 3 times again. That's pretty arbitrary. And that is in the same app!
I have an 8 MP camera! Except it defaults to 6 MP. I didn't even know that until I was writing this post and went into the settings and saw that it was set for 6 MP. I thought the face detection was broken. The little reticule didn't pick up the faces no matter how often I touched them. Oh but that's a setting too. I need to go into it Settings and turn that on.
You see how this could be confusing to a non-techie, or even a techie. The iPhone may not have as many features (I wish it had different effects like my Droid X) but the features it does have just work. I don't need to tinker with them to turn them on. It has a 5 MP camera and it shoots in 5 MP. It doesn't start with 3 and wait for me to turn it up to 5.
This is just a few examples. I'm finding more every day.
Now, don't get me wrong. I really like my Droid X. I think like an arranged marriage (afterall it was issued to me by work) I'll grow to love it. But is it as easy to use as an iPhone? No it is not.