• After 15+ years, we've made a big change: Android Forums is now Early Bird Club. Learn more here.

milestone on the 3g US

So what's the bottom line here. I've read this whole thread and a lot of people saying no and people saying yes.

Does the Milestone work on AT&T's 3G network if so which model should I look for when buying?

Thanks.
 
So what's the bottom line here. I've read this whole thread and a lot of people saying no and people saying yes.

Does the Milestone work on AT&T's 3G network if so which model should I look for when buying?

Thanks.


- Any "Milestone" will work on At&t's network "via an Edge connection". There is no debate about this.

- The "Canadian" Milestone, yet to be released, is the only version which will work on At&t's network "via a 3G connection"...per listed specs.

Given that the "Canadian" version will most likely be branded by, and purchased thru, the Canadian telco, one would have to have the telco provide the unlock code, in order for 3G connection to work on At&t. It would be better to get an "unbranded/unlocked" version, if possible, if you are looking to use it on At&t's network.
 
- Any "Milestone" will work on At&t's network "via an Edge connection". There is no debate about this.

- The "Canadian" Milestone, yet to be released, is the only version which will work on At&t's network "via a 3G connection"...per listed specs.

Given that the "Canadian" version will most likely be branded by, and purchased thru, the Canadian telco, one would have to have the telco provide the unlock code, in order for 3G connection to work on At&t. It would be better to get an "unbranded/unlocked" version, if possible, if you are looking to use it on At&t's network.

Exactly, for those who are on AT&T in the US and want a Milestone you'll have to get the "Canadian Milestone" if you want 3G. The phone officially be released on the 18th of this month. Be sure to buy it unlocked to avoid any issues. Also check if the phone is from Telus. :)

Motorola Milestone?
 
Exactly, for those who are on AT&T in the US and want a Milestone you'll have to get the "Canadian Milestone" if you want 3G. The phone officially be released on the 18th of this month. Be sure to buy it unlocked to avoid any issues. Also check if the phone is from Telus. :)

Motorola Milestone?*|* 3G+*|* Phones*|* TELUS Mobility



It actually launched today on Telus WITH THE BANDS THAT SUPPORT AT&T 3G. 600 Unsbusidized.

Motorola Droid for AT&T with 3G – $600CAD and Work | These are the Droids
 
Exactly, for those who are on AT&T in the US and want a Milestone you'll have to get the "Canadian Milestone" if you want 3G. The phone officially be released on the 18th of this month. Be sure to buy it unlocked to avoid any issues. Also check if the phone is from Telus. :)

Motorola Milestone?*|* 3G+*|* Phones*|* TELUS Mobility

Looks like it will support HSPA+, nice. Now the next question is, "is that $599 Canadian, or $599US"?

:p

I'd still try to hold out for a "non-telco branded" phone, but if that's all that's available, so be it.
 
Looks like it will support HSPA+, nice. Now the next question is, "is that $599 Canadian, or $599US"?

:p

I'd still try to hold out for a "non-telco branded" phone, but if that's all that's available, so be it.


The Telus Device, I believe is unbranded, and its 599 CAD with GST AND PST comes down do 672 Total CAD. In US THAT IS 644.

From the pictures the Milestone isn't branded
 
The Telus Device, I believe is unbranded, and its 599 CAD with GST AND PST comes down do 672 Total CAD. In US THAT IS 644.

From the pictures the Milestone isn't branded

Yep, there is no branding visible on the mock phones they have in the display cases in the stores either, so I'm thinking we'll probably see no branding on the real phones either.
 
T-Mo also uses 2100. I'm posting from my N900, which has same radios as Milestone, and I've been on 3G and 3.5G all day. I have simultaneous voice/data as well...but is only costing me $40/mo. for both services

:)
T-Mobile uses 1700/2100 for 3G which the N900 has.

The Milestone will not work on 3G
 
So it WILL work on ATT 3G bands right? It supports all of the required frequencies and everything, so if I bought an unlocked one right now, it would work out of the box correct? I don't want to buy an $800 brick ;)

Speaking of the price, any word on when it'll get reasonable? I could do $600 MAYBE, but for $800, I could get three (count 'em) netbooks.
@rfkrocktk;telus.ca just released the Milestone this week and goes $599.canadian without contract.
 
So, I was down in Bellevue/Seattle last weekend and popped in my ATT & TMO sims into my "EURO QUAD NON NORTH AMERICAN UNLOCKED UNBRANDED (did I forget anything?)" Milestone and I could not get 3G. What I did get was the fastest Edge I've ever experienced on the ATT. Normal edge speed on TMO. Yes, the APN settings were all correct. I had my iPhone 3GS as well w/my Fido sim in it and roaming on ATT the 3GS was MARGINALLY faster than the Milestone on Edge.

Now back in Vancouver, my Milestone with the Fido sim is crawling on Edge.

The Canadian Milestones ARE branded. They have TELUs on the bottom portion of the slider. Just below the menu/home keys. Even if you buy the Telus phone outright w/o a contract, they will not issue you an unlock code. You will have to speak to a Level 2 supervisor, not a level 2 cust service person. I have had Telus phones and there are not just a few hoops, but levels of hoops that you've got to go through.

So, side by side, a new Telus Milestone and my iPhone 3Gs on Fido, it wasn't even close. The Milestone lagged so far in downloading 1 mg pdfs and website rendering. Especially heavy pic laden websites.
 
So, I was down in Bellevue/Seattle last weekend and popped in my ATT & TMO sims into my "EURO QUAD NON NORTH AMERICAN UNLOCKED UNBRANDED (did I forget anything?)" Milestone and I could not get 3G. What I did get was the fastest Edge I've ever experienced on the ATT. Normal edge speed on TMO. Yes, the APN settings were all correct. I had my iPhone 3GS as well w/my Fido sim in it and roaming on ATT the 3GS was MARGINALLY faster than the Milestone on Edge.

Now back in Vancouver, my Milestone with the Fido sim is crawling on Edge.

The Canadian Milestones ARE branded. They have TELUs on the bottom portion of the slider. Just below the menu/home keys. Even if you buy the Telus phone outright w/o a contract, they will not issue you an unlock code. You will have to speak to a Level 2 supervisor, not a level 2 cust service person. I have had Telus phones and there are not just a few hoops, but levels of hoops that you've got to go through.

So, side by side, a new Telus Milestone and my iPhone 3Gs on Fido, it wasn't even close. The Milestone lagged so far in downloading 1 mg pdfs and website rendering. Especially heavy pic laden websites.

I have the Telus milestone sitting beside be now and no where on the phone does it say telus not even the boot logo
 
I've actually found one spot it does have Telus, and I suspect its probably easily changed. If you pull down the notifications slider from the top bar it has "Telus" right at the very top. Aside from that, theres no branding on the phone itself (only branding of any sort is the Google logo on the back and the Motorola stuff of course)
 
Man they are going for $700 on ebay. With that high of a price I'll consider switching to Verizon instead to get the Droid.
 
I've actually found one spot it does have Telus, and I suspect its probably easily changed. If you pull down the notifications slider from the top bar it has "Telus" right at the very top. Aside from that, theres no branding on the phone itself (only branding of any sort is the Google logo on the back and the Motorola stuff of course)

That is because your activated on the telus network. It will change dependent on the network and sim you have in the phone
 
Man they are going for $700 on ebay. With that high of a price I'll consider switching to Verizon instead to get the Droid.


Its $599 from Telus, plus $42 PST and $30 GST (whatever they are), for total of $672. Does Telus charge "activation" if you are not starting service with them?
 
Just FYI it's CAD$630 if bought by someone in Alberta since there's only 5% tax.


Fair enough (thilan and Brendan). What about "Montreal"? I may pick one up if I hit the Canadian GP. On second though, NM, if I'm spending all that damn money for a trip alone, $50 won't matter either way.
 
As much as I want an android phone milestone is not worth near $700. Unfortunately there aren't any options since I'm on AT&T. Was waiting for an HTC phone to be announced for my network but nothing yet.
 
As much as I want an android phone milestone is not worth near $700. Unfortunately there aren't any options since I'm on AT&T. Was waiting for an HTC phone to be announced for my network but nothing yet.


You pay for it one way or the other. It works out to be the same, or cheaper, if you can reduce your montly costs by going to the $15 MediaNet plan (for data), or moving to a cheaper minutes plan, and supplementing the lost time via a cheaper VoIP SIP solution.

$43/mo for "unlimited everything" (what I have via T-Mobile/Skype) + $500-$700 phone, is the same, or cheaper than any equivalent plan, + any subsidized price for comparable phone, for the 2-year contract that you'd pay for.
 
You pay for it one way or the other. It works out to be the same, or cheaper, if you can reduce your montly costs by going to the $15 MediaNet plan (for data), or moving to a cheaper minutes plan, and supplementing the lost time via a cheaper VoIP SIP solution.

$43/mo for "unlimited everything" (what I have via T-Mobile/Skype) + $500-$700 phone, is the same, or cheaper than any equivalent plan, + any subsidized price for comparable phone, for the 2-year contract that you'd pay for.


I understand your point but the Euro Milestone is in mid $500's. Now that's the price I'm willing to pay. Plus I have a bad habit of changing phones way too often. The phone is not gonna last me 2 years.
 
I understand your point but the Euro Milestone is in mid $500's. Now that's the price I'm willing to pay. Plus I have a bad habit of changing phones way too often. The phone is not gonna last me 2 years.

$500 for no 3G in North America...too rich for my blood. Good luck with that.
 
$500 for no 3G in North America...too rich for my blood. Good luck with that.


I'm sorry that I'm not clear on my point. I'm not planing on getting the Euro Milestone either. What I mean is that the phone itself (forget the fees for data) is not worth $700 for the specs it has. It's not the matter if I can afford it or not.
 
Back
Top Bottom