From what I've seen so far:
- You can capitalize the first letter of a word pretty easily by just moving above the keyboard after you swipe the first letter.
- It's worked in every application I've tried it in so far.
- It does allow you to add new words relatively quickly. Tap in the word, hold a key for a second and hit space and it adds it for future use.
- Word suggestions seem to appear right above the last letter of the word you swiped, so it's right where your finger already is.
So far, so good. I haven't personally tried Shapewriter so I can't fairly compare the two, but I figured I'd mention those things since you were discussing them.
Thanks...mirrors my initial experience.
The biggest problem w/Swype that I can find (and aside from this it is very elegant, and provides a couple of options that Shapewriter could benefit from) is that you have to put punctuation into your words...
On Shapewriter, if you want to type "you're" you swipe over those letters, and you're is provided as a word option automatically...same for "he's" and "it's", etc. Easier/faster than having to pull in the punctuation manually. That and the stacked word suggestion list that appears above the keyboard (takes your eyes/finger way up the keyboard for no good reason) are the only real weaknesses I see with Swype so far. Oh - the other thing I like about Shapewriter is that if I mis-swipe/accept a word, one tap on the back (delete) button deletes the entire word so I can start over immediately...on Swype I have to delete the word letter-by-letter. Shapewriter also handles double letters automatically...that's more of a personal preference issue...whether you want to do the little loop to confirm the duplicate letter or let the keyboard guess it for you...shapewriter does this quite well in my use, so I like letting it guess and save me the squiggle move.
The ability to hold on a key to get the alternate letters, and swipe upwards to get caps (similar to the HTC Touch keyboard) are very nice options that Shapewriter lacks.
I'm going to give it a bit longer, but I think I may be returning to Shapewriter...the manual adding of punctuation for contractions really bothers me, and the vertical word suggestion list are both slowing me down a lot...too much additional eye/finger movement. However, if I hadn't tried Shapewriter first, I'd likely be very happy with Swype. The technology used in both keyboards is quite cool.
Couple of Shapewriter's issues are 1) Exclamation point isn't on the main keyboard, you have to go to the numeric keyboard to get to it - I never realized how much I use exclamation points!; 2)Keyboards are more crowded than the Swype keyboards.