Yay! I figured it out!
So here was the issue. The 1 click method was obsolete and was disabled with an update to make it not work anymore from Samsung. However, The older version of superuser was still in the phone. This either caused a conflict with the updated superuser rooting method, Or, Samsung designed an update to put the phone in read only mode when the older version was still installed. In either event, I had to use the boost unroot to clean out the older version first and then root it again with the updated root, success!
Thanks Mydian! I got working flash and hulu apk's if you need them! hulu apk works on any device (or so I am told)
night!