Please don't take offense, but do you read? I clearly stated defective phone as a reason. My issue is that people always assume the phone sucks (aka not their phone, the brand/model) and sensationalize the problem as everyone, when its usually others (on crappy networks) or faulty hardware.
Do you read? In my post I said was that both I and the OP know that not everyone has the issue, but it IS an issue with SOME Incredibles. Just like you say that people with the issue ALWAYS assume the phone sucks, people without the issue ALWAYS assume the people complaining about the issue that they're calling someone on another network that has issues. Just like you get irritated when people deal in absolutes like ALL Incredibles have this issue, those who have the issue get irritated when those who don't also speak in absolutes and say NO Incredibles have the issue.
Many of these people have experienced this issue calling other Verizon customers who had no problems with their previous phone, but have the issue here. Hell, I've had the issue calling landlines before, how would you explain that as anything but an issue with this phone. I'm not saying that what you are talking about doesn't happen, but that doesn't mean EVERY instance happens that way.
Again three things from my previous post.
First, the OP was not complaining about the phone so much as how the CSR handled things when he made a good faith call to get the issue addressed.
Second, no two devices are exactly alike, no matter how tight the tolerances are, there are still tolerances and while one device may be unaffected, another will be affected.
Third, those of you who don't have the issue, that's great, but don't try and tell someone who has the issue phone in hand that they are not having the issue because you don't. For an explanation why that is, read the paragraph above.
It's ironic you won't believe a rumor without proof you can see, yet you can troubleshoot a device without seeing or holding it. Not saying it can't be done, but you usually need someone holding the device to act as your proxy eyes and hands.
In closing, say two guys have the same car bought at the same time with the same mileage, and one has an alternator go out, does it make sense for the other guy to say the guy with the issue did something wrong to make that happen? If not, then why would it seems more plausible with cell phones. Different devices (same model) can break down at different times, but it can happen through no fault of the devices user. Keep that in mind.