from technically the stand point of is the root any different....no its not....it uses the same exploit to gain superuser access.
my point is that...if you are new to root or dont know what you are doing....not reading up on it, not installing the computer drivers, not installing the sdk, not installing clockwork recovery........then you are heading down a bad path
people with limited information who either quickly google stuff or dont follow the information out there are the most likely to brick (or think they brick) their phones.
since they didnt take the time to install the drivers and adb (which is neccessary to restore bricks a lot) or install odin, etc etc they are in for a world of hurt.
i only think 1 click root should be available to devs who are constantly trying things out and loosing root, just so they can click thigh and root quickly to get back to work
the average android noob has no place using these things imo