OG Droid Incredible user here.
The Droid Incredible is my first smartphone (technically second; I originally got the Motorola Devour--perhaps the worst decision in my life) experience...and I love it. HTC really stands behind its tagline of, 'Quietly Brilliant'. Immediately out of the box that's what I thought. I was overly impressed with the design, responsiveness, and HTC Sense. I could not put the phone down for the first 12 hours, and after almost 2 years of owning the device, there are only minor scratches and worn areas on the phone. I've treated this phone like I do my vehicle. Its been good to me, and I've been good to it.
When I heard the announcement for the HTC Thunderbolt I immediately thought, "Man. This is going to be the Incredible on steroids," but much to my surprise it was the opposite. There wasn't much of a difference between the two devices unless you count 3G and 4G, but given its battery life, I didn't find it a worthy investment or upgrade. Then the Incredible 2 rolled out. I couldn't believe it. Here I thought, "THIS is my next upgrade! The phone I love got a sequel!" But again, I wasn't at all impressed with the features of the phone. There were marginal differences between the two devices and it contained no 4G chip, so I decided to pass on it as well. A few months back I got antsy. The Droid Bionic, Droid Charge...none of these interested me. Then I came across a device called the HTC Vigor. Finally, I said to myself, "Yeah. This is it. This is the one! Finally. A worthy upgrade from my beloved Incredible!"
Then the news of a 'Nexus Prime' filtered in.
Prior to getting the Incredible, I originally wanted the Nexus that was suppose to come to Verizon. Considering how much I despise TouchWiz, I was convinced that I would not be getting a Samsung device. If I had to put up with a skin, it was going to be the brilliantly designed HTC Sense that I've grown accustomed to...but this 'Nexus Prime' was rumored to be different, to be the 'Pure Google Experience.' The more I followed it, the more interested I became. What I saw was more than an Android device. It was the next line of defense against the iCraze. It was the next step in smartphone evolution. It was the Galaxy Nexus.
Ever since then I've retired my desire for the (now) HTC Rezound. Looking at the design of the device, Sense 3.5, and some other features I realize that this still isn't much of a difference from my Incredible. Don't get me wrong. The Rezound's specs and features are pretty amazing, but I was looking for HTC to do something far more brilliant with Sense and the phone's design; and while Beats by Dre is great, it almost appears too gimmicky. I also failed to mention a disappointment I've found with HTC, and that is updates. The Droid Incredible community went through painful waiting periods for Froyo and Gingerbread. When rumored news that HTC 'discontinued' future updates for the Incredible I knew right then and there I did not want to put up with that type of service anymore. One of the other reasons I'm hopping on the GNex is because the devices are first in line to get OS Updates. There's no waiting for the developer to tear their skin apart and modify it for the update, which then causes delays. We get it and the phone still works as intended.
But hey. This is what is so brilliant about Android and its devices. We have options. We aren't given a single model and are forced to wait a year for the next one. If the Galaxy Nexus is too large, there are 14 other options you have to chose from. If you don't like MotoBlur, Samsung, HTC, and LG have other phones (of the same caliber) for you to chose from. Android gives us the opportunity to chose a device that best suits you the individual consumer.
So whichever device best suits your personal needs and desires, go with that one!