I just recently bought the Captivate from the Premier store online at no contract for $200 (ATT employee discount). However, a few days after receiving the phone and using it, when I was checking my account online, I noticed a status message saying my account info was not accurate at the time because of an ongoing upgrade process. After calling ATT, they confirmed that by buying this phone I had "upgraded and signed a new 2 year contract."
No where during the checkout process was this indicated, in fact, every single page through the checkout process had "no contract price" on it. There wasn't even an option to choose a rate or data plan (I already had data on my old phone). In fact, even now when I log in to the Premier site, I still see the option for a no contract $200 Captivate, yet the people at Premier insist that when they pull up the Premier site and pricing, they see nothing of the sort. They say it's either $199.99 w/ 2 yr contract or $499.99. They even say that it was impossible for me to buy it for $200 and that the other prices quoted from other Premier posters (above) at $372 do not exist.
I'm currently in the middle of an open case with them to investigate this matter, because they refuse to remove the 2 year contract and let me keep the phone for $200 as advertised. I did not want to renew my contract, otherwise I would have not gone to all this trouble to secure the no contract pricing quoted to me. I just wanted to let anyone who bought a Captivate from the Premier site at no contract price to be aware. You might have also been unknowingly signed to a new 2 yr contract too. Call ATT to check.