Long time lurker, first time poster
Let me preface this by saying, obviously, that I can't wait for the Nexus!
With that being said, I'm currenlty using a "dumb" phone, and have been waiting to get a smartphone since July. I almost got a Charge but a friend talked me into waiting for the SGSII, and my heart broke when VZW decided not to carry it. Then I was very excited to hear about the Nexus. But after watching the live presentation on Oct 19th, and waiting over a month after unveil, I think I'm about ready to opt for the "rental" program and here's why.
1) While we don't have a date, the only concrete answer regarding the Nexus is before the end of the year.
2) No one knows, but at this point in time, consensus is that the Double-Data promo will be up at the end of November (likely) before the Nexus release. And 4 gb vs 2 gb is huge. (Also, paying a 35 dollar restock fee is well worth it to lock down this data contract)
3) If, worst case scenario, the Nexus were to be delayed and released after the Jan 15th exchange date, I'd much rather have ANY smartphone for the next month and a half +...
I hate to say it after waiting 6 months for a smartphone, but I think it's time to "rent" in my situation. Hopefully the Nexus will be out before the extended return date...but I'd go nuts waiting an additional month and a half anyway. Heck, it'll be worth my sanity and time (by not checking the internet for updates every half hour) just to have something.