MSUgEEk
Android Expert
I probably shouldn't get started on school punishment. Too much crap on both sides to ever have a perfect solution. But... In this situation, here is what I see wrong.
1. Letting the child decide the punishment. Nope. Wrong.
2. Violating district rules. Sorry, but if they are there, they need to be followed. Not saying whether it is a good rule or not, but it was in effect at the time of the punishment, the administrator violated the rules, and he needs to be punished as well.
3. Parent second guessing. Your daughter made the choice, you approved it, if you didn't ask about force levels before approving it, your fault. If you think a spanking is a light tap on the behind, well... sorry. The point of corporal punishment is to discourage offenders from repeating the offense. Guarantee you the girl would think twice before commiting the same offense again... except, back to number one, you give her an out.
Agree on every single point.




