Yeah all this is making me rethink my position on tiered data. I used to think I hated the idea, but more and more I'm thinking it would be a good thing.
Buy a block of data, and then use it either for your phone, or tethered to your computer, or both. For instance, if you are on a 5 gig plan then it doesn't matter if you're rooted and tethering, not rooted and tethering, not rooted and not tethering, or any other combination you can think of... so long as you stay under 5 gigs, then you paid for all your data.
Then everyone who says, "well I paid for it right"? Would be correct. And it would no longer be stealing since you'd have paid for all the data you used. Seems fair to me.
But I don't know that the providers really want to include tethering in their tiered plans because that takes away the $20 bucks they charge to do so. Which seems unfair to me. If you are going to charge us $50 bucks (or whatever) for 5 gigs of data, then we should be able to use up to 5 gigs of data any way we want to. There will no longer be this argument that 'your stealing data' if you pay for 5 gigs and don't go over that. How would it be stealing?
So yes, I do agree with the fact that it's been stealing up to this point (and yes, I've stolen some). But once our contracts become tiered, I don't think that accusation will hold true any longer.